beccabun PE
Sneaky mofo
The mediwiz did great this round!
EB Mafia
- Thread starter ChebyshevII PE PMP
- Start date
Help Support Professional Engineer & PE Exam Forum:
You made one save. Which is great in any game! You bought the town an extra day.
An interesting dynamic of multi-cop games is that the doctor can't protect both of them.
Dothracki PE
Where is my mind?
I did have @txjennah PE and @EyehatethePEexam as mafia lean if you go back to my spreadsheet. @squaretaper LIT AF PE was an unknown. I think I assumed @txjennah PE by process of elimination. That was later confirmed after I was lynched and added to the confirmed townie list.
beccabun PE
Sneaky mofo
Well I'm ready for another round, I gotta redeem myself.
I'd really love to know the sequence of cop investigations.
I guess specifically I'm curious about when @SaltySteve approached me and ask if I was a cop. Was that a genuine question? I assume that I had been investigated.
At that point I seriously considered lying and pretending to be the cop, which would seem to be easier to pull off when there are multiple.
I guess specifically I'm curious about when @SaltySteve approached me and ask if I was a cop. Was that a genuine question? I assume that I had been investigated.
At that point I seriously considered lying and pretending to be the cop, which would seem to be easier to pull off when there are multiple.
LyceeFruit PE
Woodchipped Voice of Reason
- Joined
- May 25, 2018
- Messages
- 5,926
- Reaction score
- 3,121
oh hi guys
beccabun PE
Sneaky mofo
oooh now I feel like Lady Whistledown with some secrets to spill....
- Joined
- Apr 24, 2017
- Messages
- 9,797
- Reaction score
- 2,414
One save and then picked wrong the rest of the time, including @Roarbark who managed to get killed before I could night save him!
- Joined
- Apr 24, 2017
- Messages
- 9,797
- Reaction score
- 2,414
I will say if it hadn't been for rps/rng leaning maf, we could have done it. We had the mafia figured out, but the fates were not with us.
Also, what @RBHeadge PE said.
I just knew @EyehatethePEexam was dead multiple times.
But yall took @txjennah PE from us. I was assuming she'd make it to the endgame laying low.
I just knew @EyehatethePEexam was dead multiple times.
But yall took @txjennah PE from us. I was assuming she'd make it to the endgame laying low.
Good game everyone! Great modding @RBHeadge PE !
With the larger group, I enjoyed the extra mafia/extra cop.
With the larger group, I enjoyed the extra mafia/extra cop.
****. Now I feel even bad for missing yesterdays vote.
^ @vhab49_PE was killed by the death eaters during the night
The Death Eaters win!
gg all!
Death Eaters (mafia)
@squaretaper LIT AF PE
@EyehatethePEexam
@txjennah PE
@jean15paul_PE
@JayKay PE
Aurors (cop)
@beccabun PE
@MadamPirate PE
Mediwizard (doctor)
@vhab49_PE
Programming notes:
The RNG choose all special characters and roles. In a defiance of the odds, it picked straight five female players and I was beginning to wonder if this was going to look fixed. The RNG evened itself out at the end.
The thought on doing a Hunger Games with numerous special roles made me want to try something new this game. It didn't have the time to research the properly so I went simple, We had a lot of players so I added an extra mafia member to make it harder but balance it with an extra cop. I'd been planning this concept for a while. I split the max number of investigations between the cops. They had less investigations than mafia members so it "forced" them to find each and think optimally. I figured this was pretty balancing at the time. From my vantage point, I could see the town use some creative tactics to get the most value of their limited resources. I like this new dynamic and how it can change things up a bit, but I can certainly see us going back to the normal rules especially for limited-player games. These rules wouldn't work for a game with a limited number of players.
- Joined
- Apr 24, 2017
- Messages
- 9,797
- Reaction score
- 2,414
Not that you got to truly experience it, since they deded you early.
fify
When I gamed things out, I figured that @txjennah PE and @squaretaper LIT AF PE would be figured out based on POE. But that assumed a branch where @EyehatethePEexam was eliminated instead of you.
LOL! You were investigated by both cops on day 1. You never had a chance.
The rest were:
MP: nikr, roar, jk
beccabun: duran, mp, <intentional skip>, blueblueprint
Whether she knew it or not, the doctor was always protecting a cop. Well at least up until the last couple days. On Day 3 I think @vhab49_PE figured out that @beccabun PE was a cop. How? idk.
I felt honored!
I also urged the group to investigate @JayKay PE after that happened, since a small feeling in my intestines told me she was part of it!
Also, I'm curious about the first night "no attack". Was this planned or was it mis-communication somehow?
It looks like I'm a prime target for both investigations and nightkills. Neither side trusts me! 
Edit: Well, not really. At least I wasn't investigated twice by different cops on Day 1 (@jean15paul_PE ). That's hilarious!
Edit: Well, not really. At least I wasn't investigated twice by different cops on Day 1 (@jean15paul_PE ). That's hilarious!
There were errors by both sides in this game. The lack of a nightkill on night 1 hurt the mafia. But the RNG/RPS consistently benefited the town. I RNG'd the tie last night before the RPS came in, and roar lost. The RPS came in 10 seconds later, and certainly within the allowed time, so I deferred to it for transparency. And roar still lost. The lack of voting by townies on several days also hurt the town - this happened several times so it can't be attribute to anyone in particular.
I gamed out the endgame Day 6. It looked really good for the town. Like: "Were in the endgame now" gif territory. But all that assumed that there weren't two mislynches and everyone played their part.
Hahaha, no everyone just forgot to vote for a nightkill.
From my perspective: it looked like everyone simply forgot to name a target.
