EB Mafia

[JayKay PE]

i can mod next week if we need someone. still not prepared to play

It's either you or me frantically trying to mod (I think I have night shift work happening soon, so prob not happening).

 

[RBHeadge PE]

...I...I don't know.  Wait.  Can a doctor save a mafia person?

Yes. But its a HUGE gamble by the mafia. The mafia has to select one of their own and count on both: 1) the doctor being alive* and 2) and that the doctor will protect the same person they selected. The latter seems like a big stretch without the use of PMs. If these don't happen all they are doing is literally killing their win probability. I suppose the reward is a guaranteed win for one mafia member. 

*after night 2 in this context

Has that been done before?

No, because it's risky af.

 

[Tiger15]

Yes. But its a HUGE gamble by the mafia. The mafia has to select one of their own and count on both: 1) the doctor being alive* and 2) and that the doctor will protect the same person they selected. The latter seems like a big stretch without the use of PMs. If these don't happen all they are doing is literally killing their win probability. I suppose the reward is a guaranteed win for one mafia member. 

*after night 2 in this context

No, because it's risky af.

Well, the mafia could just not target someone one night, since with the new rules we don't learn WHY no one was killed.

Then whoever the doc protected would be trusted because it will be assumed that the mafia targeted them. Still would require the doc protecting a member of the mafia. But eliminates the risk of targeting one of their own.

 

[RBHeadge PE]

I don't see why not.  I mean, if the Dr THINKS they are a good guy and attempt to save them, but then the Mafia wouldn't try to off their own in the night, would they? So it would have to coincide with the mafia not nightkilling, so could be possible, I guess?

So in tourney rules:

• The mafia must nightkill every night. If they don't select a target, a random non-mafia person will be targeted instead.
  
• if the JoAT uses the doctor action and successfully saves their target then the JoAT will receive a message from the game mod that they successfully saved <player name>. Further, the mod will announce in the public thread that no one was nightkilled.
  

In EB classic rules:

• The mafia does not need to nightkill every night. IIRC, there were two occasions where the mafia forgot/neglected to name their nightkill target.
  
• If the doctor successfully saves the target of a nightkill attempt then they will receive no PM from the mod that they were successful. The mod will announce to the thread that <player name> was targeted by the mafia and saved by the doctor
  
  When the vigilante or serial killer is included in the rules then the above message is changed to <player name> was targeted last night but saved by the doctor; or something similar where there is no indication if they were targeted by the mafia or vig/SK
  

However with all of this written, I'm not sure if we are playing classic EB or a tourney/EB hybrid.

 

[MadamPirate PE]

So in tourney rules:

• The mafia must nightkill every night. If they don't select a target, a random non-mafia person will be targeted instead.
  
• if the JoAT uses the doctor action and successfully saves their target then the JoAT will receive a message from the game mod that they successfully saved <player name>. Further, the mod will announce in the public thread that no one was nightkilled.
  

In EB classic rules:

• The mafia does not need to nightkill every night. IIRC, there were two occasions where the mafia forgot/neglected to name their nightkill target.
  
• If the doctor successfully saves the target of a nightkill attempt then they will receive no PM from the mod that they were successful. The mod will announce to the thread that <player name> was targeted by the mafia and saved by the doctor
  
  When the vigilante or serial killer is included in the rules then the above message is changed to <player name> was targeted last night but saved by the doctor; or something similar where there is no indication if they were targeted by the mafia or vig/SK
  

However with all of this written, I'm not sure if we are playing classic EB or a tourney/EB hybrid.

I should be announcing who didn't die, but for two things: 1. I couldn't figure out how to fit it in my IKEA narrative, and 2. I like the mystery. 

Apparently, I've been a bad mod. *slaps own hands*

 

[JayKay PE]

I thought we were playing normal EB rules, but with no PM?

 

[RBHeadge PE]

Two plus two always makes five

You might want to get your calculator checked before the test in October.

 

[MadamPirate PE]

I thought we were playing normal EB rules, but with no PM?

Yes, with a mod who is being a terrible human and not announcing who got saved by the doc.

 

[RBHeadge PE]

I should be announcing who didn't die, but for two things: 1. I couldn't figure out how to fit it in my IKEA narrative, and 2. I like the mystery. 

Apparently, I've been a bad mod. *slaps own hands*

1) You're allowed poetic license. 2) You can run it that way, but it does marginally add to the mafia win percentage vs baseline.

I wouldn't agree with your second sentence.

 

[Tiger15]

You might want to get your calculator checked before the test in October.

"...before the test in October." Is that 2020 or 2021? LOL

I shouldn't joke like that. I know this is super hard on people trying to sit for exams.

 

[Tiger15]

We have an excellent mod

 

[Dothracki PE]

You might want to get your calculator checked before the test in October.

They both say it...I am definitely going to fix that 

 

[RBHeadge PE]

 I should still hold a grudge, y'know with the dumbass town lynching me on day 1, but I'll give you a little advice here anyway. The town doesn't need potentially-missing "saved by" messages, or the claims of an alleged doctor to figure out the known townies this round. The voting record of those townies speak for themselves.

 

[Roarbark]

1) You're allowed poetic license. 2) You can run it that way, but it does marginally add to the mafia win percentage vs baseline.

I wouldn't agree with your second sentence.

@ #2, which isn't necessarily a bad thing given our historical win rates, IIRC. 

@MadamPirate PE oh stop it. When you're mod you're allowed to do whatever you want. Like bring me back to life.

 

[RBHeadge PE]

They both say it...I am definitely going to fix that 

View attachment 18230

did you replace the processors with Intel Pentiums 1.9999999578796598 chips?

 

[Roarbark]

They both say it...I am definitely going to fix that 

View attachment 18230

A man of culture, I see.

 I should still hold a grudge, y'know with the dumbass town lynching me on day 1, but I'll give you a little advice here anyway. The town doesn't need potentially-missing "saved by" messages, or the claims of an alleged doctor to figure out the known townies this round. The voting record of those townies speak for themselves.

I was on the fence whether to even post cause of this ^, but I was pretty confident I was getting night targeted, so .

 

[RBHeadge PE]

@ #2, which isn't necessarily a bad thing given our historical win rates, IIRC. 

@MadamPirate PE oh stop it. When you're mod you're allowed to do whatever you want. Like bring me back to life.

Has anyone been keeping track of town vs mafia wins? I know someone was keeping track but I don't know if they kept it up or not? I feel like the mafia had a pretty good streak for a couple months there.

 

[MadamPirate PE]

We have an excellent mod

 

[Roarbark]

Has anyone been keeping track of town vs mafia wins? I know someone was keeping track but I don't know if they kept it up or not? I feel like the mafia had a pretty good streak for a couple months there.

Not sure about that. I haven't been. I may be spouting propaganda here. 

 

[DLD PE]

1) You're allowed poetic license. 2) You can run it that way, but it does marginally add to the mafia win percentage vs baseline.

I wouldn't agree with your second sentence.

Maybe it was intentional to give the mafia a boost since they had to drive an Audi.