EB Mafia

[Roarbark]

 

[DLD PE]

Current Reads:

Mafia++

@RBHeadge PE

Lean Mafia

@Roarbark, @SaltySteve

Lean Townie

@jean15paul_PE

Neutral or not enough info

@NikR_PE

@squaretaper LIT AF PE

@blybrook PE

@ChebyshevII PE

 

[Booo]

Current Reads:

Mafia++

@RBHeadge PE

@RBHeadge PE are you mafia?

 

[Tiger15]

It has mostly to do with reading what people post.  

For example, when @vhab49_PE and @jean15paul_PE were mafia, Vhab attempted to post a "game relevant" analysis and in doing so, call herself out as a townie.  She said, "I'm taking myself off the suspect list because I know I'm a townie."  Now, that sounds innocent and might be the right thing to say to deflect, but something bothered me about that statement (or maybe I've been reading too many Lee Child novels).  

Vhab could have said, "I'm a townie", or "I'm a regular townie" or "I'm leaving myself off the suspect list because I'm a townie."  Or, "I'm not mafia".  Any of that would have done the job.  But instead, she said, "I KNOW I'm a townie."  Almost like, I investigated myself and found out I'm a townie (because I'm NOT a townie and maybe someone SHOULD investigate).  It almost sounded like it subconsciously came out of guilt, as if she was aware what she was saying was wrong so she was trying to convince herself (as well as the audience) that she was a townie...."I KNOW I'm a townie."  lol just sounded strange so I called her out on it.

Later, after we found out she was mafia and we were all trying to figure out the other mafia, I caught JP writing something verbatim to what Vhab said.  It was a small thing, but too much of a thing to be purely coincidence.  Either one told the other what to say and repeated it publicly, or they shared something in a PM and without realizing said the exact same thing, almost like they planned to say it but failed to coordinate who should say it, so they both did.

So there is an example of my analysis.  I have no special powers this round, just a regular townie.  I only voted for Salty this round because he asked.  I have no other reason so suspect him.  

I have my eye on someone else.

Interesting... I can say that was purely a coincidence. But I'm still slightly impressed.

EDIT: I actually meant to ask you because you said you had something that you'd reveal later. I almost PM'd you, but didn't want to appear to violate the no PM rule.

 

[Tiger15]

 

[RBHeadge PE]

My current reads

Mafia+++

Mafia++

Mafia+

salty (not doing himself any favors); roar; duran

neutral

jean, cheb, rbheadge, square

townie+

nikr, bly

townie++

townie+++

 

[Roarbark]

"I decided not to disclose how many mafia/joat cause I said so." Interesting. 

 

[ChebyshevII PE PMP]

My current reads

Mafia+++

Mafia++

Mafia+

salty (not doing himself any favors); roar; duran

neutral

jean, cheb, rbheadge, square

townie+

nikr, bly

townie++

townie+++

Lol. Putting yourself in as neutral. Good strategy.

 

[blybrook PE]

Ya know, it's hard to figure out who is who right now and I need to vote. 

Salty hasn't been doing himself any favors, maybe he wants to be free for the weekend without thinking about this round of mafia. 

At this time, I'm going to rely on the randomizer:

@chart94 today's vote is for @jean15paul_PE. Purely randomizer. 

 

[DLD PE]

@chart94 I change my vote to @RBHeadge PE

 

[Booo]

Went to the lake and forgot to vote.

 

[blybrook PE]

it appears there is a 4 way tie, unless I'm missing something.

@chart94, can we get a vote update and direction for path forward?

 

[chart94 PE]

Sorry guys was setting up momma charts 55th birthday present! 

 

[chart94 PE]

Vote update:

2- @SaltySteve

1 - @RBHeadge PE

1- @DuranDuran

1- @jean15paul_PE

 

[chart94 PE]

I will extend deadline to end of the hour because I was so late and couldn’t give the town the proper vote update!

 

[Tiger15]

I don't like the idea of casting the deciding vote on day 1.

I'm kinda leaning townie with Salty for no explainable reason.

A 5 way tie sounds like a lot of fun.

 

[Tiger15]

@SaltySteve i retract my vote for Salty and instead vote for @NikR_PE

 

[chart94 PE]

Time! Ok all players send in 10 rps the one that loses the most will be eliminated 

 @jean15paul_PE @RBHeadge PE

@SaltySteve @blybrook PE

@DuranDuran 

 

[blybrook PE]

Vote update:

2- @SaltySteve

1 - @RBHeadge PE

1- @DuranDuran

1- @jean15paul_PE

Time! Ok all players send in 10 rps the one that loses the most will be eliminated 

 @jean15paul_PE @RBHeadge PE

@SaltySteve @blybrook PE

@DuranDuran 

How'd my name get back on the list?

 

[ChebyshevII PE PMP]

How'd my name get back on the list?

I think he must have meant @NikR_PE?