EB Mafia

[DLD PE]

I'm not into ties. @JayKay PE I vote for @RBHeadge PE for the time being.

 

[BlueBlueprintPE PMP]

Ummm....not really lol. Trying to tell us could have been a subtle hint such as, "I'm pretty sure I won't be saved by anyone." But that might have been too much info. I dunno lol. Ok nevermind you tried and we still killed you . It wasn't me!

I thought about that ... but yeah, figured it might have been too much and didn't want to break any rules ...

 

[Dothracki PE]

I thought about that ... but yeah, figured it might have been too much and didn't want to break any rules ...

No rulebreaking to reveal your role when you are alive when done properly. Only if you are nightkilled and you reveal your role would you break a rule.

 

[BlueBlueprintPE PMP]

No rulebreaking to reveal your role when you are alive when done properly. Only if you are nightkilled and you reveal your role would you break a rule.

true ... but also figured if i revealed too much this early if i wasn't lynched by the town i'd just end up being nightkilled.. so.. not much benefit there.

 

[Dothracki PE]

true ... but also figured if i revealed too much this early if i wasn't lynched by the town i'd just end up being nightkilled.. so.. not much benefit there.

Very likely, but always have to think of the long term affects as well.

 

[JayKay PE]

Current vote:

x1 @Dothracki PE (needs to be made official with an '@' by @EyehatethePEexam PE)
x1 @txjennah PE (becca)
x2 @RBHeadge PE (doth, duran)
x1 @beccabun PE (txj)
x1 @squaretaper LIT AF PE (MP)

 

[JayKay PE]

true ... but also figured if i revealed too much this early if i wasn't lynched by the town i'd just end up being nightkilled.. so.. not much benefit there.

This is kinda why I like the no PM rule. It really requires you to think long-term about stuff and be super sneaky on both sides. It why it was much more 'balanced' with the mafia vs. townie game, since the townies really need to work hard to outwit each other.

It's also why I was killed first round/night whenever we played it because I suck at being sneaky.

 

[JayKay PE]

TRRRRRRRRRRRIPLE POST

 

[Dothracki PE]

It's also why I was killed first round/night whenever we played it because I suck at being sneaky.

Sounds like you are being sneaky right now.

 

[BlueBlueprintPE PMP]

not puppy pictures ... but a bit of an engineering feat in moving (temporarily) a 30+ foot, 23kip clock tower so we can install a 30-ft deep sewer main tie-in just below the clock-tower location. the first picture was taken from the top of the parking garage a couple blocks away. the second picture is it's new temporary location until we are done with the work. at which point we will move it back (and demo the concrete pad)....

 

[Tiger15]

true ... but also figured if i revealed too much this early if i wasn't lynched by the town i'd just end up being nightkilled.. so.. not much benefit there.

Not true. Even if you came out and said, "I'm the doc, don't kill me!" and got nightkilled, that's still a benefit to the town. Instead of the town killing you, they would have killed someone else... and that someone else could have been a maf. No guarantee. But between the two options: (1) town kills the doc and mafia kills a townie or (2) town kills someone else who might be mafia and then maf kills the doc. Option 2 is better for the town.

 

[Eye Hate Landscaping PE]

Please @ me to make this offic

I've changed my mind, @JayKay PE I vote for @RBHeadge PE because they haven't been mafia in a while and I have a gut feeling.

 

[BlueBlueprintPE PMP]

Not true. Even if you came out and said, "I'm the doc, don't kill me!" and got nightkilled, that's still a benefit to the town. Instead of the town killing you, they would have killed someone else... and that someone else could have been a maf. No guarantee. But between the two options: (1) town kills the doc and mafia kills a townie or (2) town kills someone else who might be mafia and then maf kills the doc. Option 2 is better for the town.

Well at least now the benefit to the Cop is that any investigations that come back not-reg, will be maf. But, with no PMs, this knowledge is restricted to the cop, so.... it def makes it tougher for a townie win!

 

[JayKay PE]

Current vote:

x1 @txjennah PE (becca)
x3 @RBHeadge PE (doth, duran, eye)
x1 @beccabun PE (txj)
x1 @squaretaper LIT AF PE (MP)

 

[JayKay PE]

Sounds like you are being sneaky right now.

Can't be sneaky. I'm mod.

 

[JayKay PE]

Not true. Even if you came out and said, "I'm the doc, don't kill me!" and got nightkilled, that's still a benefit to the town. Instead of the town killing you, they would have killed someone else... and that someone else could have been a maf. No guarantee. But between the two options: (1) town kills the doc and mafia kills a townie or (2) town kills someone else who might be mafia and then maf kills the doc. Option 2 is better for the town.

Except that one time I had everyone convinced I was the cop...because I didn't vote for @vhab49_PE when they got dog-piled killed. But I was maf. And I felt super bad.

 

[JayKay PE]

Well at least now the benefit to the Cop is that any investigations that come back not-reg, will be maf. But, with no PMs, this knowledge is restricted to the cop, so.... it def makes it tougher for a townie win!

...

Unless sleeper maf hasn't been activated.

 

[beccabun PE]

@JayKay PE I change my vote to @RBHeadge PE unless they explicitly state that they aren't mafia.

 

[BlueBlueprintPE PMP]

...

Unless sleeper maf hasn't been activated.

very true...

 

[DoctorWho-PE]

@jaykay since I feel like poop, I'm going to vote for @txjennah PE mainly because I can't be bothered to look who else is playing.