Well, met up with girl #1 and her friend, tagged my neighbor along to give me a fair assessment.
Girl #1 is really cute, less normal than I'd anticipated (in a good way), and I will probably go out with her again. The bad part was that I ate sushi before I went, and for whatever reason, I was feeling really nauseous for the better part of the night, to where I got up and went to the bathroom twice thinking I was going to blow chunks. As a result, I probably came off quieter/less interested than I was, but it was more of a "hey, I don't want to vomit in your hair" kind of thing. Luckily the feeling subsided for the remainder of the evening.
Girl #1 is really cute, less normal than I'd anticipated (in a good way), and I will probably go out with her again. The bad part was that I ate sushi before I went, and for whatever reason, I was feeling really nauseous for the better part of the night, to where I got up and went to the bathroom twice thinking I was going to blow chunks. As a result, I probably came off quieter/less interested than I was, but it was more of a "hey, I don't want to vomit in your hair" kind of thing. Luckily the feeling subsided for the remainder of the evening.