EB Mafia

[Tiger15]

@MadamPirate PE was targeted for haunting but was miraculously saved by the doctor.

Can someone post some reads? I don't know how to feel about this. Did the ghosts hunters target a mafia or did the doctor save a townie?

 

[Tiger15]

@lyceefruit (can't tag her now for some reason)

I think if she hasn't logged into the site since they moved it to the new platform then you can't tag her.

 

[steel]

I think if she hasn't logged into the site since they moved it to the new platform then you can't tag her.

I know Rb tagged her in the 2021 WTTS thread, and I believe she logged in back in April, if I remember right.

 

[RBHeadge PE]

Yeah, the woodchipper is a mafia thread staple.

I can't tag lycee anymore either. Not sure what's going on there.

also:

 

[steel]

Did the ghosts hunters target a mafia or did the doctor save a townie?

Well, if the ghost hunters targeted a mafia, would the doctor have saved them? Unless both MP and the doctor are both mafia. But my understanding is that the doctor is always a townie, correct? #Newbquestion

 

[MadamPirate PE]

Doctor is always a townie.

Also, y'all confirmed I'm a townie, which means the maf is gonna get me tonight. So.

 

[txjennah PE]

@Dothracki PE I vote for @NikR_PE

 

[JayKay PE]

The woodchipper is the most famous of EB mafia kills so far, borrowed from @JayKay PE of course

THE SLADER. I LEAVE FOR A WEEK AND MISS AN AWESOME STORY.

Obviously, I'm going to have to mod again sometime soon.

 

[DLD PE]

@Dothracki PE I vote for @JayKay PE to mod after you.

 

[Dothracki PE]

THE SLADER. I LEAVE FOR A WEEK AND MISS AN AWESOME STORY.

Obviously, I'm going to have to mod again sometime soon.

 

[Dothracki PE]

Vote Count:

@NikR_PE - 1 (TXJ)

 

[Tiger15]

Well, if the ghost hunters targeted a mafia, would the doctor have saved them? Unless both MP and the doctor are both mafia. But my understanding is that the doctor is always a townie, correct? #Newbquestion

The doctor is always a townie, but the doctor has no idea of anyone else's identity. So when they pick someone to save, it could be a mafia or a townie. The mafia know who each other are and wouldn't target one of their own. It's the mafia target, not the doctor save, that proves townie-ness.

This mechanic is different. The ghost hunters could target a mafia, but they could also unknowingly target a townie. So the ghost hunters may not know who they are targeting, and the doctor may not know who they are saving. I don't think this confirms anything.

Hopefully the cop got a confirmed townie PM going and was able to identify the doctor. That's the winning strategy.

 

[DLD PE]

The doctor is always a townie, but the doctor has no idea of anyone else's identity. So when they pick someone to save, it could be a mafia or a townie. The mafia know who each other are and wouldn't target one of their own. It's the mafia target, not the doctor save, that proves townie-ness.

This mechanic is different. The ghost hunters could target a mafia, but they could also unknowingly target a townie. So the ghost hunters may not know who they are targeting, and the doctor may not know who they are saving. I don't think this confirms anything.

Hopefully the cop got a confirmed townie PM going and was able to identify the doctor. That's the winning strategy.

Not always.

 

[steel]

The doctor is always a townie, but the doctor has no idea of anyone else's identity. So when they pick someone to save, it could be a mafia or a townie.

So the save doesn't mean MP is NOT mafia....

 

[MadamPirate PE]

So the save doesn't mean MP is NOT mafia....

Very rarely does the mafia NK one of their own.

I'm legit a townie, but don't believe me if you don't want to.
Dearest doc, give me a holla.

 

[steel]

Very rarely does the mafia NK one of their own.

I'm legit a townie, but don't believe me if you don't want to.
Dearest doc, give me a holla.

You were almost killed (but saved by the doctor) by a haunting. If I'm correct, isn't that the hunter ghosts, NOT the mafia?

There has to be a reason why the hunter ghosts decided to make an attempt on you.

 

[steel]

I could be reading the whole thing wrong, though. But I just thought the hunter ghosts and mafia were two separate groups.

 

[Tiger15]

10) All players who have been eliminated may not contribute to gameplay publicly except in the private threads they may be a part of. (*New Rule*)

This is making me sad.
Could use some @RBHeadge PE insights right now

 

[DLD PE]

You were almost killed (but saved by the doctor) by a haunting. If I'm correct, isn't that the hunter ghosts, NOT the mafia?

There has to be a reason why the hunter ghosts decided to make an attempt on you.

One of them was probably high on candy and not thinking straight, especially after a Titans OT win.

You are correct. The hunter ghosts and mafia are two different items.

EDIT:

Forget what I just said above. Oops I'm not allowed to contribute.


Oh wait, screen grabs not allowed. I'm about to get banned.

 

[steel]

Hey, helping the newbie isn't considered active gameplaying, it's called being nice! lol