EB Mafia

[RBHeadge PE]

So, in the interest of game balance and neutrality I'm inclined to just play this out as if this was a dogpile lynch and let the chips falls where they may.


From a human perspective, we can let her withdrawal (transfer to Ilvermorny) in peace. The votes for her today will be nulled. If necessary, I will take limited action behind the scenes to ensure proper game balance. regardless of her role, *something* will need to be adjusted. I've gamed it out for all three roles, and some branching based on other actions, and I think I know what to do. Let me know before 13:00 eastern if you are okay with this option. If there are any objections then I will take no action.

 

[LyceeFruit PE]

I wasn't thinking of it from a game angle. I just didn't want to "kill" her off. Seemed like a shitty week already, why not let her ride off into the sunset on her broom chasing a golden snitch or whatever?

From a game standpoint, we gain no information from killing off LF. It's a mercy kill and a free pass for Mafia to take us down by one if she's a townie. We glean no voting patterns from that. And even worse, if she's a cop or doc then we're shooting ourselves in the foot.

I'm fine being taken out by a hippogriff tonight, it's fine. OR DIE BY NORBERT!

@RBHeadge PE plz kill me by dragon! since there are no woodchippers at Hogwarts anyway

 

[RBHeadge PE]

FWIW, I'd rather not restart the round.

 

[RBHeadge PE]

Or alternately, we can null the votes for lycee for today, and let @chart94 play her assigned role. I think this is the cleanest option.

 

[Dothracki PE]

Or alternately, we can null the votes for lycee for today, and let @chart94 play her assigned role. I think this is the cleanest option.

No objections here

 

[DLD PE]

No objections here.

 

[FlangeheadPEAZ]

TBFH I volunteer as tribute to be murderized today. This new site is terrible and I'm not in the mood to deal with it.
We're euthanizing Banjo this weekend for behavior. Re-homing him to my best friend is not working.
The shelter made the decision for us. There are no more options left for him.

Sorry to read this...I can't even imagine how it feels..stay strong.

 

[FlangeheadPEAZ]

Or alternately, we can null the votes for lycee for today, and let @chart94 play her assigned role. I think this is the cleanest option.

No Objections...

 

[Eye Hate Landscaping PE]

No Objections...

Seconded (or fifthed or whatever we're on now). Sorry for @LyceeFruit PE loss...I've been there and don't wish it on anyone.

 

[JayKay PE]

Or alternately, we can null the votes for lycee for today, and let @chart94 play her assigned role. I think this is the cleanest option.

On one hand, I want to go this route, on the other...I kinda want to just play it out. We've had previously rounds where someone 'suicided' due to life or other issues, which I think is part of the game, where we all dogpile lynched so they'd be able to leave. I think @txjennah PE did it once, due to work getting super busy, and @Unintended Max P.E. does it almost every round.

I don't like thinking that my votes counted for nothing. If that was the case I feel like the entire first night should be allowed to replay.

 

[Eye Hate Landscaping PE]

If she was a death eater (mafia) would the other evil-doers offer alternatives to voting her out? Did @chart94 get voted out as an innocent but revived as a criminal? This is twistier than a 60's sock hop.

 

[squaretaper LIT AF PE]

No objections, but has to be death by Norbert!

 

[JayKay PE]

If she was a death eater (mafia) would the other evil-doers offer alternatives to voting her out? Did @chart94 get voted out as an innocent but revived as a criminal? This is twistier than a 60's sock hop.

That's another thing, if lycee is a maf, how does that change the game by switching with chart, who was a townie? Does that mean chart now is that special character? Which changes the dynamic again.

I know this will probably make me a target, but I really think for fairness sakes we just let @LyceeFruit PE suicide tonight by Norbert. Or Gringotts dragon. And keep playing.

 

[MadamPirate PE]

Here's my two cents:
Let's say we leave Lycee in the game. She'd be dead within a couple days due to not voting.
I feel like even @squaretaper LIT AF PE has done this before by admitting he's maf and getting piled on and he's not maf.
What's the difference between Lycee claiming to be maf and her asking for us to murder her due to life events?

 

[Tiger15]

I'd assume that we'd just play it out, but also I trust @RBHeadge PE judgement. He's probably the most knowledgeable here. So I defer my opinion to whatever RB thinks is the best way to go.

 

[RBHeadge PE]

I'm seeing enough quasi-objections that I'm inclined to just play it where is lays.

 

[Eye Hate Landscaping PE]

@RBHeadge PE , I formally change my vote to @LyceeFruit PE per THEIR wishes and because I wear jeans to work everyday- so this will be an experiment if a singular jean is evil and plurality makes jean's likable or if all jean's are good.

 

[DLD PE]

I'm wearing jeans today, so all good.

 

[Booo]

So, in the interest of game balance and neutrality I'm inclined to just play this out as if this was a dogpile lynch and let the chips falls where they may.


From a human perspective, we can let her withdrawal (transfer to Ilvermorny) in peace. The votes for her today will be nulled. If necessary, I will take limited action behind the scenes to ensure proper game balance. regardless of her role, *something* will need to be adjusted. I've gamed it out for all three roles, and some branching based on other actions, and I think I know what to do. Let me know before 13:00 eastern if you are okay with this option. If there are any objections then I will take no action.

I am ok with either. But to fulfill my obligation @RBHeadge PE , i vite for @LyceeFruit PE

@LyceeFruit PE , sorry to hear that.

 

[DLD PE]

Sorry @LyceeFruit PE !

@RBHeadge PE I vote for @LyceeFruit PE