Home Improvement/Repair Questions

Professional Engineer & PE Exam Forum

Help Support Professional Engineer & PE Exam Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
maybe that 20; extension ladder would pay for itself by now ;)  ?
My roof is steep as hell.  I have no business being on it.  I watched the last young, spry contractor damn near fall off the thing as he tried to traverse it.  

 
Hoo boy, CasaSquare's pool (we just moved in) got real cloudy in just a couple days. We were so busy moving I didn't check on the pool and it turns out the seller turned off the pump when they left. Time to shock it and maybe change the filter. Any pool advice? Never had one before. I'll consult the Google, too, of course.

 
just be prepared to drop a lot of time and $$$$$$$!!!!!   chemicals, parts, tools, toys, electricity...it adds up fast.  we got rid of ours several years ago.  we were dropping $600+ a year for a 3 month season and only ended up using it a couple times.

 
just be prepared to drop a lot of time and $$$$$$$!!!!!   chemicals, parts, tools, toys, electricity...it adds up fast.  we got rid of ours several years ago.  we were dropping $600+ a year for a 3 month season and only ended up using it a couple times.
Ughhhh, I refer to it as "surprise pool" because I didn't want it, need it, prepare for it, or budgeted for it. But it came with the house and LadySquare wants it. I'll give it a couple years I guess!

 
would assume in CA you can get a good bit of use out of it?
I'd better use it now! It's all good, just griping about something I didn't ask for and I just want to do it right. It's 104F as I write this, so I guess you wacky EB weirdos better hit me up next time you're here! Everyone who walks in the door gets a standard-issue  "walking around beer." :bananalama:

 
Back to the topic: forgive my ignorance for I am a mere mechanical engineer, but do I need to hire someone to tell me if a wall is load-bearing or not? LadySquare wants to knock down a wall to expand the master bath. Do I need to call a guy? Inspector? Civil/structural engr? Architect? Billy-Bob down the street?

 
you should be able to decipher - do your ceiling joints run parallel to the wall or perpendicular to it? (may have to climb in attic)
I'll take a look and report back! I've only been living there for 4 days and I haven't poked around the attic and haven't paid attention to the ceiling. Thanks @Road Guy!

 
Back to the topic: forgive my ignorance for I am a mere mechanical engineer, but do I need to hire someone to tell me if a wall is load-bearing or not? LadySquare wants to knock down a wall to expand the master bath. Do I need to call a guy? Inspector? Civil/structural engr? Architect? Billy-Bob down the street?
you need to follow the framing and understand the load path.  RG's suggestion is good but basic.  If you have high ceilings or irregular framing it may not be as obvious.  Start cheap with getting an estimate and the contractor should be able to tell/confirm your suspicions.  If there's doubt find a local structural guy.  Depending on the age and configuration of the house and being in CA it might be designed to resist lateral loads from seismic events in addition to vertical loads.  A seismic shear wall could be just as important as a vertical load bearing wall, if there's ever a quake.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
you need to follow the framing and understand the load path.  RG's suggestion is good but basic.  If you have high ceilings or irregular framing it may not be as obvious.  Start cheap with getting an estimate and the contractor should be able to tell/confirm your suspicions.  If there's doubt find a local structural guy.  Depending on the age and configuration of the house and being in CA it might be designed to resist lateral loads from seismic events in addition to vertical loads.  A seismic shear wall could be just as important as a vertical load bearing wall, if there's ever a quake.
This is sort of what I'm worried about. High ceilings (to me) and irregular framing (to me). Again, I am a mere mechanical. I guess the root of my question is who can I call to make the final decision whether or not I can take a wall down (really, I'm moving it).

 
Last edited by a moderator:
This is sort of what I'm worried about. High ceilings (to me) and irregular framing (to me). Again, I am a mere mechanical. I guess the root of my question is who can I call to make the final decision whether or not I can take a wall down (really, I'm moving it).
You planning on doing the work yourself or hiring someone to do it?  If it's DIY I'd suggest retaining a local structural engineer to look and provide a stamped plan on what needs to be done to remove it.  If you're going to have a contractor do it, then get some estimates from remodeling contractor's and when you select one, be sure to put in the contract that you want a letter/plan stamped by a PE for the work.  that way if god-forbid anything goes amiss (even like settling and causing cracking to finishes inside) you have support material to have him pay for any necessary repairs.  I obviously don't know the specifics of your house it might be very simple, or...it might not be.  Good luck.

 
You planning on doing the work yourself or hiring someone to do it?  If it's DIY I'd suggest retaining a local structural engineer to look and provide a stamped plan on what needs to be done to remove it.  If you're going to have a contractor do it, then get some estimates from remodeling contractor's and when you select one, be sure to put in the contract that you want a letter/plan stamped by a PE for the work.  that way if god-forbid anything goes amiss (even like settling and causing cracking to finishes inside) you have support material to have him pay for any necessary repairs.  I obviously don't know the specifics of your house it might be very simple, or...it might not be.  Good luck.
I'm definitely having someone else do it. I'm busy with other DIY projects! I'll definitely request that my contractor get the planned work reviewed, I just didn't know if contractors are typically able to conclude what walls can be demo'd.

 
I'm definitely having someone else do it. I'm busy with other DIY projects! I'll definitely request that my contractor get the planned work reviewed, I just didn't know if contractors are typically able to conclude what walls can be demo'd.
If a contractor can't determine if a wall can be removed, they have no business working on your house.

 
Back
Top