EB Mafia

[RBHeadge PE]

Wait what? He was the JOAT?

View attachment 17921

what the shit?!

 

[MadamPirate PE]

what the shit?!

I NEED TO KNOW

 

[MadamPirate PE]

I'm also going to die quickly in the next round - I've been Maf two of the last three games. 

Also, next mod: chart is ALWAYS maf. cut the guy a break!

 

[JayKay PE]

what the shit?!

*frames and puts this on the wall*

 

[Roarbark]

Okay, I'll be on my way now, since I'm supposed to be extremely busy doing work, and I just delayed my day by several hours. 

 

[SaltySteve PE]

Yes, you noticed the logic inconsistency this morning wrt MP. There were three underlying assumptions, not all of which could be correct. 

1) The mod always reported information correctly

2) everything @vhab49_PE said was true

3) everything @SaltySteve was true

One of the above had to be false with his "investigation" of MP. At this point there were several ways to figure out that (3) was false. I need to get to my other game, so I'll give some quick ones:

• No one actually saw was Salty wrote first before he edit/redacted his message. It was in the eye of the beholder to interpret. His initial reads on didn't supply any new information. The rest of his story was was filled in later with things that conveniently fit after-the-fact.
  
  The cover fell apart when he made a logical inconsistency this morning. A safer thing would have been to say @squaretaper LIT AF PE was mafia. No logic holes in that story - everyone would be willing to believe it
  
• Assume (1) and (2) are correct and the above is the only explanation.
  

[*]You can game out a scenario where vhab was wrong on interpreting the investigations, but even that didn't quite line up with the 'facts' Salty presented

[*]You can look at gamer behavior to figure out that roar and jean were townies. They were actually trying to make sense of it. Whereas Salty wasn't actually giving real information. MP was silent.

[*]MP's vote on Thursday to help protect Chart - and I got nightkilled immediately thereafter

[*]other observations

@SaltySteve was certainly the MVP this round. Hat tip to him.

The JP on 6/3 thing was purely luck. I was trying to set it up as a Me VS Vhab and get the rest of the mafia to back me. It actually read that I motion detected JP on 6/3 before and I later redacted it to try to quiz VHAB and give some credence to me being JOAT so I could set up an argument to have the town lynch her. When She was like "I saved VHAB" I just rolled with it hoping that someone had seen the post before I redacted it.

 

[MadamPirate PE]

• You can look at gamer behavior to figure out that roar and jean were townies. They were actually trying to make sense of it. Whereas Salty wasn't actually giving real information. MP was silent.
  
• MP's vote on Thursday to help protect Chart - and I got nightkilled immediately thereafter
  

I stayed quiet to stay under the radar. Also, I figured I'd tipped my hand on saving chart. 

 

[SaltySteve PE]

what the shit?!

I think this makes me the happiest. I couldn't fool you on my role but there was still a plot twist you didn't see. I'll go to bed with a smile on my face tonight.

 

[RBHeadge PE]

I think this makes me the happiest. I couldn't fool you on my role but there was still a plot twist you didn't see. I'll go to bed with a smile on my face tonight.

I figured @DuranDuran was the other JoAT when no one else spoke up. oh well

 

[Tiger15]

@squaretaper LIT AF PE, why didn't you reveal yourself and your info?

 

[Tiger15]

This morning I was all about @SaltyStevebeing maf and I noticed he was protecting @MadamPirate PE. My working theory was that he lucked up and the other JOAT was already dead. But he really did convince me. First had me questioning @vhab49_PE then had me questioning myself like, "maybe I am maf and don't know it."

Well played sir.

 

[Tiger15]

I am genuinely mad at myself for letting go of my @SaltySteve suspicion. 

Also, I tried to channel my inner @RBHeadge PE... Then I realized I don't have an inner @RBHeadge PE; I just eat a lot of fish.

 

[tj_PE]

Lol yeah and I kept recheckinf my responses to joats making sure I didn't fuck up

 

[tj_PE]

When jp was like somethings fishy I was like OMG THIS IS REAL LIFE 

 

[tj_PE]

Then nah lemme just blind trust this joat here.. 

 

[squaretaper LIT AF PE]

 

[squaretaper LIT AF PE]

Wait, Square you were the JOAT???????????????????????????????????? Bruh.

I TOOOLLLLLDDSSSS YOUUUUS

 

[squaretaper LIT AF PE]

@squaretaper LIT AF PE, why didn't you reveal yourself and your info?

Maybe I still don’t understand the rules (I’m, generally, pretty dumb), but I thought I’m not supposed to reveal who I am...

 

[squaretaper LIT AF PE]

I stayed quiet to stay under the radar. Also, I figured I'd tipped my hand on saving chart. 

Madam, if I had some spare shackles I’d throw them at you! Er, I mean, well played.  :rotflmao:

 

[squaretaper LIT AF PE]

Also, well modded @tj_PE! Thank you!

Now, would you like some parm?