I don't mind the Challengers, but when stacked up against the Mustangs and Camaros I tend to agree with most car magazine comparisons in that they're a distant 3rd place. Between comfort, features, power, handling, and overall package they're no match, but it also comes down to appearance. Some people just think they look better, and there's nothing wrong with that... :ghey:
The biggest complaint from Challenger owners is the fact that they essentially need to buy the $50k+ SRT8 version just to keep up with the SS Camaro and 5.0 Mustang (both costing over $10k less). But it's not really a concern for most of them because they like the car itself and aren't worried about the muscle car wars.