Confirmed Mrs. Supe fried the trans in her old CRV. Fluid was dark brown and smelled like Kingsford. Amazed she managed to go almost 150K on a trans that had never been serviced in its entire life (heh).
So, we've test driven a new CRV, and test drove an Outback last night. Below is a copy/paste of what I sent to my father, who was trying to convince me to buy the Scoobydoo.
Outback Pros:
· Interior fabrics were nicer than the Honda
· Room for the dogs
· Drives more like a car than an SUV, a bit easier to maneuver
· Roof rack was a nice feature
· Felt like there was more space for the back seat passengers
· AWD
· Rear seats recline
Outback Cons:
· Brakes were god awful. I should not be able to put a spongy pedal to the floor on a car with 58 miles on it
· No power, CVT transmission always seemed to be trying to hunt for the right RPM range
· Interior plastics felt very cheap
· MPG slightly lower than the CRV
· We thought the radio/electronics were less intuitive
· Some of the features Mrs. Supe wanted (rear USB ports for electronics, etc.) are only available on the higher trim 2018 models
· No Apple or Android compatibility (just regular Bluetooth)
CRV Pros:
· General nicer/more luxury oriented fit and finish on interior
· Electronics seemed more intuitive, comes with Apple and Android compatibility
· Electronics are what Mrs. Supe wants – front/rear USB ports, etc.
· Very quiet cabin – little road noise
· Front passenger space felt bigger
· Cargo capacity with seats both up and folded down is bigger, more headroom for two dogs
· Smooth engine/transmission – felt like better acceleration than Subaru, doesn’t hunt for RPM’s as much
· Overall safety rating tied the Outback, but the lane assist and cruise control of the CRV was lightyears ahead
· More comfortable of the two cars in terms of ride quality – suspension is much better than previous years (you can do a quick lane change and not feel like its going to topple over), and soaks up the small bumps and rough surfaces much better than the Outback.
CRV Cons:
· 2WD
· Interior fabric feels very cheap
Ties:
· Front seats – Subaru is plushier, CRV is firmer. CRV feels like it puts a slight push on your shoulders, but Subaru feels like it has a strange lumbar arrangement/push on your upper back. Neither felt great, but I noticed the Subaru irritating me more after 15 minutes of driving. Mrs. Supe didn’t seem to notice either way.
· Both have the rear seat release handles in the cargo area
· Pricing – About a wash with the 0% financing. The out the door price on the Honda was slightly slower than the best price off invoice he could get us on the 2017’s. They were anxious to get rid of them, so it was right around $3K off the Subaru invoice pricing, which was much more off sticker than we could get on the Honda.
· Resale value – both hold well, the CRV is actually a bit better and is the #10 overall best car for resale. The other 9 are all full size trucks.
Overall you couldn’t go wrong with either. Both of us seemed to reach the same conclusion, though – the CRV felt like the better car overall for what we do with it. If we NEEDED AWD, it would be a no brainer, because the CRV would outprice the Subaru at that point. At the end of the day, neither of us could find anything wrong with the Honda other than the fact that the interior fabrics felt very cheap.