I took the mechanics/materials section. First time examinee; I'm hoping that was also my last (successful) attempt. I found the morning to be tougher than the afternoon, which surprised me. I swore I was going to get a beating on the afternoon session since I didn't feel like I prepared enough for dynamics/kinematics-style questions. But I guess coming out of the exam and not wanting to immediately re-open the books to check your thinking is a good sign? Definitely found value in having taken the School of PE online video sessions. The best method to prepare was definitely drilling practice problems. Even Lindeburg's practice exam helped me exercise concepts that were important, despite their higher difficulty relative to the actual exam.
On a separate note, I hated when everyone started leaving in the afternoon with about 45 minutes remaining in the exam. Surely, one would want to use every minute they had to make the best guesses possible on questions. I stayed for the entire duration of the exam, but I did get to the end of the afternoon session with about 25 minutes to spare (and about 5 guesses that I had to go back and try to solve).
As a project engineer for a chemical plant (i.e. an engineer that typically contracts out any engineering design calculation work), this was challenging. But I'm hopeful for a positive response in December, and I do think that beyond bragging rights, there will be real value and opportunity with having the PE license. But I'm getting ahead of myself... now we wait for the results.