Everyone's opinion counts! I thought you were a Trekkie from a few previous movie discussions.Sorry, not a real "Trekkie". So I guess my opinion doesn't count.
I don't disagree with that. But you have to first get the fan-base acquainted with a likeable crew. Especially since they are completely different from the original variety. Then you can start going off on tangent stories IMO. That seems to be the case with these first 2 movies based on what I've all read in fan zones and various commentaries.I "like" ST but I am not a Trekkie. I know this because I have good friends who are. I may own the entire original series in glorious high definition, but I don't have any costumes or anything like that. I can argue over a few points here and there, but I can't go very far with it, like my friends can.
Sure, there are some cool ideas that are explored, but those could have also been explored in another storyline. Even with the Enterprise and original crew. Heck, just make a whole movie about their visit to just one star system, like an episode in the original series. You have to admit there is a lot of room for creativity even with the original set-up.
"Were you listening to the Dude's story?" "Well then you have no frame of reference..."Watching "The Dude" on IFC right now! Totally cool. "Smokey my friend, you are entering a world of pain."
I am certain they could have come up with some good, new material that was well within the original intent and feel of the series, if they had just ditched the Hollywood Hacks and hired some real sci fi writers.
I'll take that bet!And ST is a very valuable franchise, so they know with a new timeline, they can basically remake all the films, add subtle differences (enough to argue about, as Dr Phil says, "differences without distinction), and voila, a 'new film' that doesn't alienate fan bases.I am certain they could have come up with some good, new material that was well within the original intent and feel of the series, if they had just ditched the Hollywood Hacks and hired some real sci fi writers.
The Xindi! Another one of my favorite ST races. Man was that a good set of episodes.HAHAHA...I almost put a part in there about boarding a Borg cube or a Xindi battle cruiser to carry the elephant.
Enter your email address to join: