Check out the MIT admissions website:
http://web.mit.edu/admissions/graduate/pdf...rtment_info.pdf
EECS (Electrical Engineering & Computer Science, page 8) doesn't need GRE! My guess is they look at letters of recommendation, GPA, reputation of undergraduate school etc.
I'm not really sure what your point is. Nobody is talking specifically about applying to EECS at MIT. We are talking about the quality of GRE scores. I just mentioned MIT as an example of a top school. I didn't expect somebody to fine tooth comb their admissions requirements.
Plus, who said anything about electrical engineering. I think SSmith is an industrial engineer. I don't even know if MIT has that department.
But according to the thing you posted every other engineering discipline requires the GRE
For example, most people on this website are civil engineers. MIT requires the test for this -
http://cee.mit.edu/index.pl?iid=4455#tests
I could find the ranking website to support my statement about SSmiths quantitative score being top-notch, but I don't think that's necessary. I mean, you can't really do much better than 790.
Well, just in case-
http://www.universityportal.net/2008/04/am...ngineering.html
http://post-gre.blogspot.com/2007/06/top-5...schools-us.html