EB Mafia

[MeowMeow PE]

Ok, since the Mafia now have this information and not the townies...yes, I am the doc. Please do not kill me today or else Meow is gonna get NK'd tonight.

I’m really sorry if I get you NK. Maybe I shouldn’t have told everyone! Eek! But I thought at this point in the game full transparency might be better, or at least not hurt? But I often don’t see the consequences of things until it’s too late!

 

[Tiger15]

@MeowMeow PE do you know who you're investigating tonight?

 

[txjennah PE]

Why was he the obvious choice? Didn't he just use a wheel to take out square?

@jean15paul_PE Haha yep, which is why I asked this earlier in the game. Not intentional, just missed Steel's post announcing he was Cassandra.

 

[Tiger15]

I would suspect someone other than @MeowMeow PE to be the cop under normal circumstances...but IIRC this is a no PM round, so I think that rules things out.

I'm not sure I understand this post

 

[MeowMeow PE]

@MeowMeow PE do you know who you're investigating tonight?

Not yet. Going to wait and see how the day plays out.

 

[txjennah PE]

I’m really sorry if I get you NK. Maybe I shouldn’t have told everyone! Eek! But I thought at this point in the game full transparency might be better, or at least not hurt? But I often don’t see the consequences of things until it’s too late!

It's all good! These no PM threads definitely make things harder (in a good way!)

 

[blybrook PE]

An interesting way to start the day. Glad to hear that we've had a doc save.

 

[DLD PE]

@BlueBlueprintPE I cast a vote for @EyehatethePEexam PE for the time being.

 

[RBHeadge PE]

I'm trying to process all this on three hours of sleep.

And the only thing I can conclude is: I need caffeine asap.

 

[Eye Hate Landscaping PE]

@BlueBlueprintPE I cast a vote for @EyehatethePEexam PE for the time being.

I'm really grateful yesterday didn't go. I didn't log on until last night when time was declared. When I logged off on Thursday I assumed I was dead, so I guess I had a meaningless self-vote on Friday. I'll be a little more active today.

 

[Eye Hate Landscaping PE]

Oversimplified look, not intended as final analysis

Lit of people who did not vote for chart or MP on Thursday:
spit, cheb, bly, becca, vhab, rbh

List of people who did not vote for MP on Friday:
becca, doth, jean, meow, vhab, eyehate

Intersection:
becca, vhab

@BlueBlueprintPE I tentatively vote for @beccabun PE. I have to read back and see if anyone asked vhab if they were mafia.

 

[Spitfire6532]

I guess I can announce that I am the cop. I was going to wait until tomorrow after my last investigation to announce my findings, but since it appears the doc is still alive, and in case mafia wanted to NK me tonight, I might as well announce it now. So if we don't lynch the last mafia today, then DOC, PLEASE SAVE ME TONIGHT!!!!

I have had 4 investigations so far. Three have come back as regular townie. One has come back as not regular townie, however, they could be the doc. I am a little hesitant to announce who the not regular townie is, but I guess since it appears that Cassandra is no longer with us, and since I only have one investigation left tomorrow, then I can't see the harm in announcing it at this point in the game.

Here are the investigation results:
@RBHeadge PE - regular townie (Sorry folks that this doesn't really help us, since after last night that became apparent)
@Spitfire6532 - regular townie (HOW HAVE YOU STILL NEVER BEEN MAFIA?!?!?!?!)
@vhab49_PE - regular townie
@txjennah PE - NOT regular townie

Obviously, please don't lynch @txjennah PE today just in case she is the doc.

I have no idea how I haven't been mafia yet. It seems my fate is that of a loyal townie.

I have to look back at old posts to try to make a more informed vote today, but from what I am remembering, I will put in a vote for the time being:

@BlueBlueprintPE I vote for @ChebyshevII PE

 

[txjennah PE]

@BlueBlueprintPE I tentatively vote for @beccabun PE. I have to read back and see if anyone asked vhab if they were mafia.

vhab is a townie based on Meow's investigation.

 

[txjennah PE]

@BlueBlueprintPE I put in a placeholder vote for @beccabun PE for now.

 

[RBHeadge PE]

@RBHeadge PE was found unconscious in his room by @djl PE who was checking tickets and making sure all the passengers were comfortable and prepared for the long cold night. @djl PE called for a doctor aboard and after a very close call they miraculously were able to revive @RBHeadge PE. He had been poisoned but being part fish, the poison wasn’t fatal.

remaining passengers
@DLD PE , @RBHeadge PE, @ChebyshevII PE , @MeowMeow PE , @EyehatethePEexam PE , @txjennah PE , @eng_girl95 , @Spitfire6532 , @jean15paul_PE , @blybrook PE , @beccabun PE , @Dothracki PE , @vhab49_PE

Thanks @txjennah PE !

 

[DLD PE]

I'm trying to process all this on three hours of sleep.

And the only thing I can conclude is: I need caffeine asap.

And maybe some fish lasagna.

 

[RBHeadge PE]

I guess I can announce that I am the cop. I was going to wait until tomorrow after my last investigation to announce my findings, but since it appears the doc is still alive, and in case mafia wanted to NK me tonight, I might as well announce it now. So if we don't lynch the last mafia today, then DOC, PLEASE SAVE ME TONIGHT!!!!

I have had 4 investigations so far. Three have come back as regular townie. One has come back as not regular townie, however, they could be the doc. I am a little hesitant to announce who the not regular townie is, but I guess since it appears that Cassandra is no longer with us, and since I only have one investigation left tomorrow, then I can't see the harm in announcing it at this point in the game.

Here are the investigation results:
@RBHeadge PE - regular townie (Sorry folks that this doesn't really help us, since after last night that became apparent)
@Spitfire6532 - regular townie (HOW HAVE YOU STILL NEVER BEEN MAFIA?!?!?!?!)
@vhab49_PE - regular townie
@txjennah PE - NOT regular townie

Obviously, please don't lynch @txjennah PE today just in case she is the doc.

Ok, since the Mafia now have this information and not the townies...yes, I am the doc. Please do not kill me today or else Meow is gonna get NK'd tonight.

I've gotten some lunch and caffeine and thought this over.

The posts above are logically self-consistent and believable. The scenario(s) where this is an elaborate mafia ploy are non-credible. To execute such a scheme is extremely high risk and low-medium reward. Don't have the brainpower or time right now to type out the game-theory, so I hope it's sort of self explanatory.

I'm treating it all as legit.

 

[beccabun PE]

Targeting @RBHeadge PE was a rookie move this early in the round. I wouldn't make that move.

 

[chart94 PE]

 

[DLD PE]

Targeting @RBHeadge PE was a rookie move this early in the round. I wouldn't make that move.

I agree, except it's not that early in the round. At the same time, I'm subject to change my vote with more info.