EB Mafia

[steel]

Because even if it was luck on the wheel of names, why would I actually cast that vote if I was mafia? I'd simply spin it again. Same goes for jean. He'd simply spin the wheel again because nobody knows how many times you spun it.

 

[steel]

I maintain my vote for @DLD PE. I suggest my fellow townies start asking why he thinks mafia members would lynch their own on day 1.

 

[DLD PE]

There are several things wrong with what you said.

1) If I was mafia, I never would have voted for another mafia member, not on day 1.
2) Jean cast the deciding vote for Cheby. If he was mafia, there's no way in hell he'd cast a deciding vote for a mafia member 6 minutes before the deadline.

We can guarantee that those who voted for Cheby are practically confirmed townies. Myself, EG95, and jean.

You said there were "several" things wrong with what I said, then you listed "two", but then item #2 is something I already stated/agree with, so how is that wrong?

I don't think you're mafia based on #1/your voting, but your statements are starting to make me suspect you.

 

[Eye Hate Landscaping PE]

Remember, during a round that she was mafia, she specifically created an evil plan where the mafia wouldn't nightkill someone so they could frame a townie as the final mafia member.

Which means silence and lurking is a strategy @MeowMeow PE has used in the past as a mafia member.

I was the one she was setting up...I remember it well, have received no cookies and hence the grudge is strong.

 

[steel]

You said there were "several" things wrong with what I said, then you listed "two", but then item #2 is something I already stated/agree with, so how is that wrong?

I don't think you're mafia based on #1/your voting, but your statements are starting to make me suspect you.

Dude, you literally said "How do we know YOU'RE not mafia? You voted for Cheby..."

Please tell the court why a mafia member would lynch another mafia member on day 1.

 

[DLD PE]

Because even if it was luck on the wheel of names, why would I actually cast that vote if I was mafia? I'd simply spin it again. Same goes for jean. He'd simply spin the wheel again because nobody knows how many times you spun it.

Not me. I honor the randomizer. I really thought voting for @RBHeadge PE would get me in trouble, but if I don't honor the randomizer, it ceases to become a randomizer. But I guess it's getting me in trouble too often!

 

[steel]

Not me. I honor the randomizer. I really thought voting for @RBHeadge PE would get me in trouble, but if I don't honor the randomizer, it ceases to become a randomizer. But I guess it's getting me in trouble too often!

So if you were mafia, and the wheel landed on a mafia member on day 1, you'd actually cast that vote 6 minutes before the deadline to guarantee a mafia gets lynched?

 

[DLD PE]

I maintain my vote for @DLD PE. I suggest my fellow townies start asking why he thinks mafia members would lynch their own on day 1.

I can answer that. I would lynch my own in desperation (I've done it before!), but not on day 1. I don't think others would either, unless they wanted to try something new. But I don't think @steelnole15 would do that.

 

[DLD PE]

So if you were mafia, and the wheel landed on a mafia member on day 1, you'd actually cast that vote 6 minutes before the deadline to guarantee a mafia gets lynched?

No, because I would not wait 6 minutes until the deadline to spin it. Besides, Mini-me is getting ready for bed by then.

 

[DLD PE]

I'd simply spin it again.

You'd spin a randomizer again?!? SUSPISH! lol j/k

Anyway, I'm the wrong guy to lynch. Just sayin'

 

[Eye Hate Landscaping PE]

I can answer that. I would lynch my own in desperation (I've done it before!), but not on day 1. I don't think others would either, unless they wanted to try something new. But I don't think @steelnole15 would do that.

I like big but's and I cannot lie

 

[Booo]

I like big but's and I cannot lie

"You other brothers can't deny"

 

[MeowMeow PE]

I'm not saying the evidence is damning at this point, but we have very little evidence at all. You were silent on day 1 aside from some likes and reactions, I agree with the observation that that's unusual for you but you're new enough that I don't have any hard tells on you yet.

Which means silence and lurking is a strategy @MeowMeow PE has used in the past as a mafia member.

I went back and looked at the past 3 games I've played, because you guys were making me start to think I'm crazy. I didn't do a great job at getting exact count of reactions, but here goes:
-Becs Round First day: I reacted/liked post more than 5 times, and I commented only once saying "damn that sucks" because Nole was lynched and he was doc. Did not vote first day. Role: Townie
-Blue's Round First Day: I made 0 comments, and did not vote. Reacted to posts at least 3 times. Role: mafia
-RBH Round First Day: reacted at least 3 times, commented 3 times, but that is because I was defending myself because Spit voted for me first day. Did not vote. Role: Cop

Silence and lurking is my strategy Day 1 no matter what role I am.

Also, @MeowMeow PE isn't really a new player, and @ChebyshevII PE is a veteran. I don't think they (along with any remaining mafs) would have voted to nightkill a relatively new player. That would be a newbish move.

@DLD PE ....then why are you voting for me???

 

[MeowMeow PE]

I maintain my vote for @DLD PE. I suggest my fellow townies start asking why he thinks mafia members would lynch their own on day 1.

Honestly, the thought came across my mind, since you are weirdly targeting me for no good reason. I was wondering if it was a ploy to gain our trust.

 

[RBHeadge PE]

Just got back from the beach, what did I miss?

 

[RBHeadge PE]

I'm assuming you meant me and not "did" for your mafia+ read. I don't blame you, but my vote was random. I blame my son lol.

Yes hence the slight mafia lean.

For clarification before it becomes an issue- is sharing a spreadsheet with the voting record and order okay for a dead player to do?

If they normally do it, then I'd think it's fine.

I have no issues with that, I just wanted to put it out there. The two people that most frequently post their spreadsheets were tied for getting offed last night.

 

[DLD PE]

@DLD PE ....then why are you voting for me???

Because @steelnole15 implied he knows something, or is in a convo with someone who knows something.

 

[Tiger15]

BlueBun updated vote count?
@steelnole15 you keeping a spreadsheet?
I want to see something, but dont' have time to ready 5+ pages right now.

Tag: @BlueBlueprintPE @beccabun PE

 

[beccabun PE]

I totally wish you could tag us as BlueBun!

Vote update

3x @DLD PE (Flange, NikR, Steel)
1x @MeowMeow PE (DLD)
1x @steelnole15 (Meow)

I believe this vote count still stands? Lots of talk over the last two pages, not a lot of votes.

 

[RBHeadge PE]

Alright, im still sort of lost. But its Flowrider time. I'll check in again before 90s music trivia.