I am about to buy a Glock in 40 caliber. I'm volunteering for my local sheriff reserves and they require 40 caliber.
They allow two makes, including Glock which I prefer (reliability, price, etc). I'm leaning toward the G23 over the G22. It's a little easier to concealed carry and my hands are not big enough to necessitate getting the G22.
By the way, I plan to buy new. The price of used Glocks is so high that I could probably get a new one for nearly the same price (with law enforcement discount). Plus I'd get three magazines ... and the cool blue box.
Not to mention, you never know if a previous owner has been shooting lead or whatever.
Also, the sheriff won't allow the comp models like yours.
So that’s what’s led me to the G23. Do you see any flaws in my reasoning? Sounds like you’ve had a fair amount of experience with Glocks and I would appreciate your feedback.