The Mandalorian (Spoilers)

Help Support Engineer Boards:

Road Guy

Administrator
Staff member
Admin
Moderator
Joined
Apr 24, 2006
Messages
29,240
Reaction score
10,372
Location
Colorado
So I think this show was pretty well done, (I think it deserves its own thread)but I have lots of questions:

  1. Why does this series (set 5 years after ROTJ) seem to ignore any acknowledgement  of the "Jedi"- maybe that is by design? Weird the mando doesnt know what the "force" is?
  2. Wouldn't most everyone in the galaxy know of Jedi Master Yoda?
  3. Was "baby yoda" F'n with the storm troopers in the last episode or are they really that bad a shot?
  4. Supposedly  next season they will introduce original SW characters?-  I think its okay as is, unless its just a one off episode with Luke passing by looking for power converters...

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Dleg

Spammer Emeritus
Joined
Nov 5, 2006
Messages
15,662
Reaction score
5,069
Location
digester
I'm not even going to read your post, but I have finally been able to get on to Disney + and have watched the first 3 episodes. I am loving it so far. Hopefully I can finish it up this week and then rejoin this thread to discuss.

 

jeb6294

Charter Member
Joined
Apr 25, 2006
Messages
2,567
Reaction score
798
Location
Cincinnati...just Cincinnati!
So I think this show was pretty well done, (I think it deserves its own thread)but I have lots of questions:

  1. Why does this series (set 5 years after ROTJ) seem to ignore any acknowledgement  of the "Jedi"- maybe that is by design? Weird the mando doesnt know what the "force" is?
  2. Wouldn't most everyone in the galaxy know of Jedi Master Yoda?
  3. Was "baby yoda" F'n with the storm troopers in the last episode or are they really that bad a shot?
  4. Supposedly  next season they will introduce original SW characters?-  I think its okay as is, unless its just a one off episode with Luke passing by looking for power converters...
I believe this is all supposed to take place on the edge of the galaxy so it could just be assumed that they are remote enough that we're supposed to believe Jedis/Yoda aren't common knowledge.

Put me in the group who thinks the first part of the last episode with the storm troopers was great. 1) Them sitting there BS-ing and bitching at each other was funny. 2) I don't think Baby Yoda had anything to do with them missing so many times, I think it was poking fun at the joke about storm troopers being horrible shots and it was hilarious.

 

ruggercsc

I was once fast and scrappy, then lost my s's
EB Supporter
Joined
May 19, 2016
Messages
1,311
Reaction score
295
Location
Tennessee
I just wanted to see a battle between Apollo Creed vs. Gina Carano vs. the Red Viper in a "Battle Royale".  Yes, Apollo Creed is past his prime, but who would win  this three way battle.  My money is on Gina.  

 

Road Guy

Administrator
Staff member
Admin
Moderator
Joined
Apr 24, 2006
Messages
29,240
Reaction score
10,372
Location
Colorado
And too bad Nick Noltes character didn’t make it!

 

Dleg

Spammer Emeritus
Joined
Nov 5, 2006
Messages
15,662
Reaction score
5,069
Location
digester
So I think this show was pretty well done, (I think it deserves its own thread)but I have lots of questions:

  1. Why does this series (set 5 years after ROTJ) seem to ignore any acknowledgement  of the "Jedi"- maybe that is by design? Weird the mando doesnt know what the "force" is?
  2. Wouldn't most everyone in the galaxy know of Jedi Master Yoda?
  3. Was "baby yoda" F'n with the storm troopers in the last episode or are they really that bad a shot?
  4. Supposedly  next season they will introduce original SW characters?-  I think its okay as is, unless its just a one off episode with Luke passing by looking for power converters...
We finished it last night. Awesome show, 4.8 stars for me. 0.2 star deduction for the single episode that wasn't quite as good, where they helped the shrimp farmers. That episode seemed a bit of a throw away, although it did introduce the shock trooper woman, who was awesome.

I think the Jedi are a forgotten thing by this time in the Galaxy. Remember, even Luke had no idea what a Jedi was, or who Obi Wan or Yoda was. The Jedi had all been killed off or hidden away a full generation before, and the Empire had risen during that time and (presumably) deleted all mention of the Jedi in their public school textbooks. 

I agree with @jeb6294, the storm trooper scene was hilarious and was total fan service, validating all previous memes.

I hope they leave the show alone and don't bring any of the main SW characters, unless like you said it's just an incidental appearance. This type of story is what I was hoping for all along since I was a kid - more of the Star Wars universe, not necessarily the Skywalker / vader story. 

Yeah we were all bummed about Nick Nolte's character getting killed. For a while we were wondering if IG-11 killed him, but it became pretty apparent that it was the speeder troopers. I was a little disappointed IG-11 didn't make it, too. 

One of my problems with the plot was when they were in the Imperial safehouse and surrounded by the storm troopers, why didn't they just shoot Moff Gideon right then?  If as Apollo Creed said, the storm troopers will scatter as soon as their commander is taken out, it seems like that would have been a decent move.

Also I think one of the things that makes this show so much better than other Star Wars (or Marvel) is how the Mandalorian keeps getting the shit kicked out of him. But they need to be careful to keep him human so that we continue to believe that is is actually vulnerable to being killed, or else most of the tension will be gone. They did a decent job of that with the last episode where he gets blown up and almost dies of a TBI, but they're getting perilously close to turning him into a Marvel super hero/Iron Man with all the non-fatal CGI falls and wall slams that he inexplicably survives.

 

jeb6294

Charter Member
Joined
Apr 25, 2006
Messages
2,567
Reaction score
798
Location
Cincinnati...just Cincinnati!
Not crazy about the guy they've got playing Moff Gideon.  He seems more like an accountant than an evil lord of the empire.  Maybe they were short staffed after the death star got blowed up and he got a field promotion because he was the emporer's CPA?

 

Road Guy

Administrator
Staff member
Admin
Moderator
Joined
Apr 24, 2006
Messages
29,240
Reaction score
10,372
Location
Colorado
Dleg - I can dig the story line about the Jedi being on the outs, I forget that Luke was sort of the last one and was 15 years after the fall of the republic.

Jeb- That guy reminds me of the guy who was the chicken franchise owner in breaking bad?

-- my bad, that dude was in breaking bad!

 
Last edited by a moderator:

jean15paul_PE

FEA Wizard
Joined
May 13, 2019
Messages
4,800
Reaction score
2,661
Location
Louisiana
The show was great. It's been officially renewed for Season 2 (not sure if they announced the dates yet). I know before it started they were talking about the possibility of a feature film, but I think the TV show format is great. I also really dig that it's been released on a schedule and not all at once. I'm looking forward to seeing where everything goes.

I agree that stormtroopers are just terrible shots. My wife was SO PISSED OFF when they kept punching Baby Yoda. :)

We finished it last night. Awesome show, 4.8 stars for me. 0.2 star deduction for the single episode that wasn't quite as good, where they helped the shrimp farmers. That episode seemed a bit of a throw away, although it did introduce the shock trooper woman, who was awesome.
I completely disagree. That was one of the better episodes. The only one that felt like a throw away to me was the Eps 5: Gunslinger, where he and the kid were hunting that lady in the desert, and the kid betrayed him.

Not crazy about the guy they've got playing Moff Gideon.  He seems more like an accountant than an evil lord of the empire.  Maybe they were short staffed after the death star got blowed up and he got a field promotion because he was the emporer's CPA?
LOL, I don't know. I see what your saying, but I'm used to seeing him (Giancarlo Esposito) play a bad guy in a lot of movies. Yeah, he's not a tough guy, but he plays a good smart, evil type. He's been a mob boss/lieutenant or just a general asshole in a lot of "black movies" (funny because he's actually Italian, but was born in Denmark). He's been in a TON of Spike Lee's movies. I'm glad to see him get some mainstream love.

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Road Guy

Administrator
Staff member
Admin
Moderator
Joined
Apr 24, 2006
Messages
29,240
Reaction score
10,372
Location
Colorado
I also like that its kind of like a western / 80's tv show where there is a different "problem" to solve each episode that is tied to, but a little unrelated to the overall story

 

P-E

Member
EB Supporter
Joined
May 21, 2014
Messages
21,544
Reaction score
2,018
Location
Boston
We ended up getting Disney + just for this show.   I think the season was well done and looking forward to next season.  Finally saw The Last Jedi and was a bit disappointed.  

 

jeb6294

Charter Member
Joined
Apr 25, 2006
Messages
2,567
Reaction score
798
Location
Cincinnati...just Cincinnati!


 

jeb6294

Charter Member
Joined
Apr 25, 2006
Messages
2,567
Reaction score
798
Location
Cincinnati...just Cincinnati!
I saw that.  I still think it's funny that people are flipping out so much because they punched baby yoda.  They do realize that it's just a TV show and baby yoda isn't real don't they?

 

Road Guy

Administrator
Staff member
Admin
Moderator
Joined
Apr 24, 2006
Messages
29,240
Reaction score
10,372
Location
Colorado
I think the best part of this show is the "Baby Yoda" nickname that got created by someone (on the Internets) & regardless of what the characters actual name is they will be forever called Baby Yoda...

 

jean15paul_PE

FEA Wizard
Joined
May 13, 2019
Messages
4,800
Reaction score
2,661
Location
Louisiana
Officially the name of the Baby Yoda character is "The Child"
The show obviously has a thing for names in the format of "The (noun)"

  • The show is called "The Mandalorian"
  • Baby Yoda is "The Child"
  • Episode list:

    The Mandalorian
  • The Child
  • The Sin
  • Sanctuary
  • The Gunslinger
  • The Prisoner
  • The Reconing
  • Redemption


 

Road Guy

Administrator
Staff member
Admin
Moderator
Joined
Apr 24, 2006
Messages
29,240
Reaction score
10,372
Location
Colorado
I reject the use of "the child" to refer to baby yoda...

 

Latest posts

Top