I wrote most of this message two days after completing the Electrical PE (Power) exam, but I decided to wait for the outcome before posting (I passed). I know that it is long, but wanted to contribute to this forum because I think that I owe this forum a thank you because it has defiantly contributed to my success of passing both the FE and PE within a year.
I took the Electrical PE ? Power exam on Friday October 27, 2006. I am not trying to scare anyone, but the exam was more difficult than I expected. I think that both the mental and physical demands make the exam even more of a challenge. I have always been an average B & C student (at least in Engineering) and I graduated with 3.1 GPA, so I was not at the top of my class, but I was also not at the bottom.
I started studying for the exam Monday July 17th, 2006 and I faithfully studied ever week 15 ? 20 hours. This consisted of everyday approximately 2 hours and most weekends around 6 ? 10 hours. I spent approximately 300 ?350 hours in preparation for this exam.
My preparation/sources consisted of the following:
1. "the other board" Passing Zone - I signed up for the "the other board" Passing Zone to help in my preparations, but I honestly have mixed feelings on what value it added for my preparation. It is a great tool if you are not disciplined enough or unable to organized your material. The teacher was very knowledgably and would answer any question posted. In my case, I followed along for most of the class, but I choose somewhat of a different approach toward the end. It did provide some additional questions each week that I thought were good examples to review.
2. "the other board" Electrical Reference Manual ? This is the main source that I used during the test and I think that everyone in the exam room had some type of "the other board" reference manual. My advice is to let this source be the foundation of your information, and know where all of the data can be found in this book. I used tabs, but I found that after I worked with the book for 16 weeks, I could turn right to any page for just about any subject matter.
3. NCEES PE Sample Exam - This is by far the best material to practice and study because it has the closest questions that resemble the actual test questions. If your state allows you to have this as a source bring it and become familiar with all of the questions and the methods of solving all of the problems. I went through this practice exam numerous times, and I think it really helped. However, I did think the actual PE exam was a bit more difficult than this sample exam.
4. NCEES FE Sample Exam ? Because I took the FE only six months ago, I had the NCEES practice exam for the FE test. This was another GREAT source. The economic questions and the afternoon electrical questions were great example to practice for the PE morning questions. I also worked these questions numerous times and I know that I got a few answer correct on the PE exam because of this source.
5. NEC 2005 ? This is a must if you are taking the Power section in the afternoon. There were 4 or 5 code questions and they were the easies questions on the test. I never have worked with NEC before taking the test, so if I can work problems and learn the code anyone can. This is a great place to pick up EASY points.
6. "the other board" sources (Practice Problems, Quick Reference, Sample Exam).
a. Practice Problems - I worked the majority of the practice problems, especially the ones that were suggested by the Passing Zone; however, I only referred to this book once during the exam. It did however provide good practice problems.
b. Quick Reference - I looked at the quick reference some during my preparation, but I never used it in the exam. If I had it to do over, I would not purchase this book again. All of the data from the ?quick reference? is found in the reference book.
c. Sample Exam - was a good book, and I used it several times in the exam and it gave some good examples, especially economics and NEC.
I took two Casio FX-115MS calculators to the exam. It seemed like most of the electrical people had this calculator, because of it ability to handle complex numbers. I used the HP-33s on the FE exam, and as a former HP fan it was the worst calculator that I have ever used. Especially when it came down to complex numbers.
I arrived at the exam at 7:15 as indicated by the card. The proctor started reading the exam instructions at 7:45. After filling in the data (i.e. name, address, etc) the exam started at 8:04. I was able to work and I think correctly answer 24 questions correctly. There were about 12 questions that I did not know, and a few more that I was able to make a good educated guess. I would estimate that I got 27 or 28 correct in the morning section. I used all 4 hours to take the morning section.
We were provide an hour for lunch, and I went to my truck and relaxed and ate a sandwich that I brought from home. I did not want to socialize with anyone because I did not want to get psychologically messed up for the afternoon portion of the exam.
The afternoon exam section started at around 1:15 after getting all of the personal data entered into the exam score sheet. As stated earlier, I took the Power portion. It was a bit more difficult than the morning section and more difficult than any practice exam that I studied. It just seemed like many of the questions they asked were questions that I would never have studied for no matter how many months/years I prepared. In addition, I do not think they could be found in just any generic reference manual/ textbook. I knew how to approach more of these problems than morning problems, but I could also see how NCEES were able to derive all of the choices. So I started second guessing myself on some of the solutions. (i.e. should I divide by sqrt 3). I finished this section in about 3 hours 45 minutes. I should have stayed the whole time because I had two problems that I could not figure out the answer. By this point in the exam, I was physically and mentally exhausted and tired. I believe that I answered 25 ? 30 questions correctly in this portion of the exam.
Keys to my success
1. NCEES Exam (both FE and PE)
2. Being really organized (tabs and matrix)
http://www.s8inc.com/pe.xls
3. Economic and Code Questions
4. Becoming really familiar with the EERM
Here are the sources that I took into the exam. They are numbered based on how beneficial they were to me during my exam.
1. "the other board" Electrical Reference Manual (highly recommend)
2. NCEES PE Sample Exam (highly recommend)
3. NCEES FE Sample Exam (highly recommend)
4. NEC 2005 Code (highly recommend)
5. FE Supplied-Reference Handbook (recommend)
6. "the other board" Sample Exam (recommend)
7. "the other board" Practice Problems (recommend)
8. Schaum's Outline of Electric Machines & Electromechanics (recommend for preparation, did not use in exam)
9. Distribution notes from College ? 3 ring binder (good source, but did not use on exam)
10. Passing Zone Weekly questions ? 3 ring binder (okay)
11. Power System Analysis by John J. Grainger (bad)
It is difficult to tell someone what to study and how to pass, but here is what I would do at a minimum.
1. Acquire the following sources
o "the other board" Electrical Reference Manual (highly recommend)
o NCEES PE Sample Exam (highly recommend)
o NCEES FE Sample Exam (highly recommend)
o NEC 2004 Code (highly recommend)
o "the other board" Sample Exam (recommend)
o "the other board" Practice Problems (recommend)
2. Develop a matrix or some method to organize your reference material, information, and solved problems. This was extremely helpful during the exam to reference. It had to stay in a 3-ring binder, but it saved be a great amount of time. See an example of mine at
http://www.s8inc.com/pe.xls
3. Study a little each night for several months (3 to 5) based on your own evaluation of your knowledge. I keep hearing that 300 hours is the average number of hours to study and pass the exam.
4. Work as many problems as possible, and focus on the NCEES sample problems and the way NCEES works/approaches each of their problems.
That is it. I hope this long message will help someone out there. I know that the information that I received from this forum has been very helpful, and I wanted to give something back after successfully passing both the FE and PE within a year. Good luck to all.
P.S.
If you download the matrix the info below defines the columns and rows
http://www.s8inc.com/pe.xls
Rows ? These are all of the topics that NCEES provides on their website as potential areas that may be covered on the electrical breadth and the power depth.
Columns ? These are all of the different sources that I became familiar with and had with me on the test as references.
FE - FE Supplied-Reference Handbook ? This is the NCEES formula book they provide during the FE Exam. Since I took the FE in 6 months before, and I became really familiar with numerous formulas in the book. I primlarly used it for engineering economics tables. So if this column is marked, it just means some corresponding data can be found in the handbook. Sometimes page numbers are provided.
Note ? These were notes from college, info from the web, and just any loose paper that I thought would be important on the exam. Again, I just referenced it on the matrix so if I needed it I could locate it quickly.
Reference Material -This provided information where I could find a topic in the "the other board" reference manual.
FE Sample Test ? This is the NCEES FE Sample test. The information in the matrix directs where examples can be found to correspond with the different topics.
PE Sample Test - Same as the FE Sample test
"the other board" Exam - Same as the FE & PE Sample test
PZ Quiz ? This were questions that I acquire from the "the other board" Passing Zone class that I took. PZ is an online class that provides a strict study schedule, a professor willing to answer any question, and more practice problems. I copied all of the problems that I thought were relevant and referenced them with my matrix.
Good Luck to All :beerchug