Thailand Soccer Team
- Thread starter Road Guy
- Start date
Help Support Professional Engineer & PE Exam Forum:
RBHeadge PE
Nucflash
I'd be a little surprised if they went that route. Unless the doctors figured that they were sick enough that needed the earlier hospitalization and the more favorable exit environment, but not so sick that they would jeopardize the rescue of the stronger victims.
Szar
Commander of the Legion of the Unholy Pear
A Clear map of the latest flooded areas.
Last edited by a moderator:
csb
Well-known member
RBHeadge PE
Nucflash
txjennah PE
UNTZ UNTZ UNTZ
I'm so relieved this story has a happy ending.
I hope all the kids and the coach can recover not only physically, but emotionally. I can't imagine what 2+ weeks trapped in a cave will do for the psyche.
I hope all the kids and the coach can recover not only physically, but emotionally. I can't imagine what 2+ weeks trapped in a cave will do for the psyche.
Szar
Commander of the Legion of the Unholy Pear
So with all said an done... was this just media over-hyped?
I do not doubt it was potentially dangerous as a diver did die or that the boys would have survived if left alone, but the efforts actually required to save them were all pretty low tech, strait forward, and rapidly advanced.
I do not doubt it was potentially dangerous as a diver did die or that the boys would have survived if left alone, but the efforts actually required to save them were all pretty low tech, strait forward, and rapidly advanced.
RBHeadge PE
Nucflash
I'm still waiting to hear that all of the rescuers have gotten out of the cave safety. One already died during operations so it's not a sure thing that everyone will get out.
Really bad things.
Over-hyped, no. I didn't really see it as top line coverage anywhere, or if it was it got pushed down fast. It wasn't covered much until they found the survivors.
K.I.S.S.
Road Guy
Well-known member
Saw this graphic of the escape set up - pretty cool and a great idea to not make the kids have to deal with the tank on their back.
The news pics showed a ton of gear brought into help the boys - lights, blankets, etc I assume and hope they wait till after the rain season ends before going back for any of that ****..
The news pics showed a ton of gear brought into help the boys - lights, blankets, etc I assume and hope they wait till after the rain season ends before going back for any of that ****..
Dexman PE PMP
Internationally PMP'n his PE-ness
Honestly, this is just another example of a lot of arm-chair social media quarterbacking of a situation that none of us were really "in the know." Yes, the media may have given us a good general idea of what was going on, but the fact that a professional rescue diver died leads me to believe this ended up being a lot more complex than any of us will ever understand.
Road Guy
Well-known member
And I think we can all agree the rescue divers must normally carry their balls in a wheelbarrow
And again where is the go fund me for hookers and blow for the wild boars!
Being that young and faced with - stay here and die or try and escape and probably die...
They deserve it!
And again where is the go fund me for hookers and blow for the wild boars!
Being that young and faced with - stay here and die or try and escape and probably die...
They deserve it!
absolutely just the arm-chair QBs will say "look how easy it is". It's my understanding that the dives had to remove their stuff individually to traverse the small passages as well as pass the kid off to each other and no-doubt keep him calm too. Nothing short of a miracle that no one was lost (except the unfortunate happening with the one rescuer).
Szar
Commander of the Legion of the Unholy Pear
I think part of it is most people don't have any experience or ability to relate to this incident. Its Scuba Diving, in a dark cave, narrow passages, with with fast currents. As I understand it from you guys, that's difficult and a very niche experience.
Personally speaking, my only comparison is snorkeling in a pool. I just though they they could strap a mask on them and pull them through the tunnel with a winch, so its probably best I deal with Electricity and not people as my job.
I think any sort of rescue attempt in a wilderness / cave setting is going to be extremely difficult, no matter how it may look from the outside. Having been involved above-water in a very difficult and traumatic wilderness rescue, I can say that getting someone out who is unable to help themselves is something that can seem impossible from the ground-level/responder view, and ultimately ends up just like it did here, with a lot of pretty simple carrying of people out, but under great difficulty and duress. It's very different to be the one on the ground who has to move someone who is injured and/or helpless through a rugged obstacle vs. someone watching from a TV set. At least these kids weren't incapacitated, that would have made this virtually impossible.
RBHeadge PE
Nucflash
There are now reports that they were heavily sedated, and carried and swam through and out of the cave via stretchers. There were earlier reports that they were given medication to reduce anxiety and keep them calm, but not to the point of knocking them out. The trouble is that those medications tend to also dull the senses or make people drowsy, which isn't a great combination for a physically and mentally challenging task. Taking them out via stretcher probably reduced risk by removing the kids unpredictable behavior from the equation. My guess is that they did some practice runs with mannequins on stretchers to see if it was viable. And once they proved it would work they implemented it.
It's all starting to make sense now why they took out the weaker first. If they were sedated and carried out, then they can't accidentally cause disruptions to later rescues.
It's all starting to make sense now why they took out the weaker first. If they were sedated and carried out, then they can't accidentally cause disruptions to later rescues.
