Geotech Problem

Professional Engineer & PE Exam Forum

Help Support Professional Engineer & PE Exam Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

PE_2009

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 12, 2009
Messages
45
Reaction score
0
Location
NJ
5 kg of soil, at natural water content of 3%, is to be mixed with water to achieve water content of 12%. How much water would you add to the above soil?

I solved above problem & came with answer of 450 grams. However, the correct answer is 436 grams. Can somebody explain it?

 
PE_2009,

The 5 kg is the total mass of the soil plus initial water.

Dry mass of soil = 5000g / 1.03 = 4854g

Initial mass of water = .03 * 4854 = 146g (Or 5000 - 4854)

Total water req'd = .12 * 4854 = 582g

Additional water = 582 - 146 = 436g

 
PE_2009,
The 5 kg is the total mass of the soil plus initial water.

Dry mass of soil = 5000g / 1.03 = 4854g

Initial mass of water = .03 * 4854 = 146g (Or 5000 - 4854)

Total water req'd = .12 * 4854 = 582g

Additional water = 582 - 146 = 436g
Please let me know, what's wrong in following solution. Some authors including Chelapati calculate amount of water to be added with following method

Total mass of soil is 5,000g which contains 3% water. To bring this soil mass to 12% water content, amount of water to be added = 5000 x (12%-3%) = 450g

 
PE_2009,
The 5 kg is the total mass of the soil plus initial water.

Dry mass of soil = 5000g / 1.03 = 4854g

Initial mass of water = .03 * 4854 = 146g (Or 5000 - 4854)

Total water req'd = .12 * 4854 = 582g

Additional water = 582 - 146 = 436g
Please let me know, what's wrong in following solution. Some authors including Chelapati calculate amount of water to be added with following method

Total mass of soil is 5,000g which contains 3% water. To bring this soil mass to 12% water content, amount of water to be added = 5000 x (12%-3%) = 450g
The water content is a ratio of the mass of water (mw) to the mass of soil (ms), not the total mass (mt) of 5000g. i.e. w = mw / ms. => initial mw = .03ms

5000g = mw + ms. You must isolate the ms before proceeding. => 5000g = .03ms + ms => 5000g = 1.03ms => ms = 4854g

For the initial water content: mw = 5000 - 4854 = 146g For the final water content: mw = .12*4854 = 582g

Additional water required = 582 - 146 = 436g

ms should be used in the short cut instead of mt: 5000/1.03*(.12-.03) = 437g Close enough to 436g. See above for derivation of 1.03.

Bottom line: general short cut = mt/(1+w)*(Δw)

 
PE_2009,
The 5 kg is the total mass of the soil plus initial water.

Dry mass of soil = 5000g / 1.03 = 4854g

Initial mass of water = .03 * 4854 = 146g (Or 5000 - 4854)

Total water req'd = .12 * 4854 = 582g

Additional water = 582 - 146 = 436g
Please let me know, what's wrong in following solution. Some authors including Chelapati calculate amount of water to be added with following method

Total mass of soil is 5,000g which contains 3% water. To bring this soil mass to 12% water content, amount of water to be added = 5000 x (12%-3%) = 450g
The water content is a ratio of the mass of water (mw) to the mass of soil (ms), not the total mass (mt) of 5000g. i.e. w = mw / ms. => initial mw = .03ms

5000g = mw + ms. You must isolate the ms before proceeding. => 5000g = .03ms + ms => 5000g = 1.03ms => ms = 4854g

For the initial water content: mw = 5000 - 4854 = 146g For the final water content: mw = .12*4854 = 582g

Additional water required = 582 - 146 = 436g

ms should be used in the short cut instead of mt: 5000/1.03*(.12-.03) = 437g Close enough to 436g. See above for derivation of 1.03.

Bottom line: general short cut = mt/(1+w)*(Δw)
Thanks for reply. I got it! Appreciate your help

 
Back
Top