45 Years Ago Today...

Professional Engineer & PE Exam Forum

Help Support Professional Engineer & PE Exam Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

knight1fox3

Jedi MASTER & Friend of Capt. Solo
Joined
Dec 30, 2009
Messages
16,366
Reaction score
4,067
Location
Brew City!
45 years ago today—on July 16, 1969—astronauts Neil Armstrong, Buzz Aldrin, and Michael Collins launched to the Moon on top of the mightiest spaceship ever built. These amazing photos from NASA's vaults show how they built and launched that spaceship—I look at them in awe and admiration.
Source: http://sploid.gizmodo.com/amazing-photos-from-nasas-vaults-show-how-they-assemble-1605378889?utm_campaign=socialflow_gizmodo_facebook&utm_source=gizmodo_facebook&utm_medium=socialflow

Some very impressive engineering accomplishments there. Across all disciplines (except stormwater :p ).

 
We were able to visit the Navy ship that picked them up when they came back. The airstream isolation chamber was pretty funny to see.

 
Could America do this today?

Reasons why I think not:

- The men who sent us to the moon were WWII vets, from both sides (ahem, Werner von Braun). Current generations simply aren't made of the same stuff, haven't experienced an event where the entire country, every man woman and child, was working together on a massive, unified undertaking. These guys had, and that experience undoubtedly served to drive them to the success of the moon program. I don't doubt that, individually, we still have talent in this country, but we are sorely lacking in the teamwork and leadership department...

- America was a manufacturing powerhouse back then. We hardly manufacture anything now - would we subcontract half the work to the Chinese?

- The space program was funded on massive marginal tax rates that today's society would never support, lest we be accused of socialism.

- It took an incredible amount of failures to achieve this success. In today's climate of scandals over every failed test of a new aircraft and the subsequent hesitantness (for lack of a better word), I just don't see this happening. We were cranking out new fighter aircraft every 2-3years back then, and went from biplanes to the moon in just 30 years. What have we done in the last 30 years? The F-35, which is still not in service (AFAIK), began life as a program over 20 years ago, if that tells you anything.

- The space program happened when EPA and OSHA didn't exist. Imagine rocket engine testing with EPA air regulations, or all those exploding rockets resulting from the learn-from-your-failures mode the space program was working under at the time.

I'll bet the U.S. could do a bang up job of faking a new space mission, though. We're now great at special effects, movies, and computer games.

(Dleg is feeling a little cynical today!)

 
Sometimes I wonder, exactly how far are we supposed to advance? Or maybe if we need another "major set back" prior to being able to go further as humans (think as in like Hunger Games).

I do disagree regarding your comment about taxes- in the 1960's NASA peak year was in 1966 when they received just under 4.5% of the national budget for spending.The percentage started to decrease slowly, but there was a massive reduction of NASA spending in mid-70's. Right around the time where there was a spike in governmental spending on welfare programs. We now spend nearly triple the amount of the federal funds on assistance with cash/housing/food than we did in the 1969 or so, and that doesn't count medical or social service type spending. I think it would probably make plenty of people happy if we were still funding programs that once made our country so great, because that is what would probably build us up again.

Also- with the advances of computer technology, I would think that the "learn as you go" destruction would be a little less frequent due to modeling and simulations... granted everything is only a theory until tested for real, but we HAVE progressed further in all manners of speaking.

I think what would prevent us from doing it today is the selfishness of our society- no one cares if we achieve something great as a country much anymore and if they do- not in a way that would take such a long term investment.

 
10447856_10152551681429571_1081471293815685314_n.jpg


 
Some of those headlines are still being used today.

 
Back
Top