When I failed Oct 18', it just never updated.
Mine updated on Tuesday, under "Pass PE Exam" to complete with Tuesday's date.
Best of luck that they just didn't get a chance to update your checklist yet.
I am a retaker.
Google "new jersey license login" - login then go to your checklist. About 30 mins ago when I was checking it had "Passed PE exam" - complete, with today's date. Nothing on NCEES website yet.