EB Mafia

[txjennah PE]

I have to say I was very happy that I picked up on @EyehatethePEexam PE 's Cassandra status when he received my vision, even with the fake news that I'm after Cheb

 

[MeowMeow PE]

That's around when I started suspecting Eye! I suspected Eye was Cassandra, but with him posting what seemed like the first reveal soon after the lynch results the same day he was triggered, I wasn't sure. So I messaged @DLD PE to ask him if he could tell me privately what specific time the Cassandra had to post their reveals by. I wanted to see if Eye posted another reveal in the timeframe Cassandra was supposed to. Then DLD said he'd post the answer to the question and clarification on Cassandra role on the public thread for fairness. I tried to ask him to wait and don't post it and just don't tell me the answer yet either, because if Eye was Cassandra, I didn't want the mafia members to figure it out after getting clarification from his post. But he posted it publicly before he saw my message asking him not to. When I saw the info, I knew then that Eye was Cassandra and I thought for sure that everyone else would figure it out. But it ended up working out!

 

[DLD PE]

Should the mafia be given an extra player, or a spy to even the teams out? Or is the game pretty well balanced now?

 

[Eye Hate Landscaping PE]

Should the mafia be given an extra player, or a spy to even the teams out? Or is the game pretty well balanced now?

It's been my experience that my side always appears to be short one player.

 

[Eye Hate Landscaping PE]

That's around when I started suspecting Eye! I suspected Eye was Cassandra, but with him posting what seemed like the first reveal soon after the lynch results the same day he was triggered, I wasn't sure. So I messaged @DLD PE to ask him if he could tell me privately what specific time the Cassandra had to post their reveals by. I wanted to see if Eye posted another reveal in the timeframe Cassandra was supposed to. Then DLD said he'd post the answer to the question and clarification on Cassandra role on the public thread for fairness. I tried to ask him to wait and don't post it and just don't tell me the answer yet either, because if Eye was Cassandra, I didn't want the mafia members to figure it out after getting clarification from his post. But he posted it publicly before he saw my message asking him not to. When I saw the info, I knew then that Eye was Cassandra and I thought for sure that everyone else would figure it out. But it ended up working out!

I think my strategy was solid. If I'm posting something I want townies to know I want to post it before the nightkill in case I'm offed. If I was mafia aligned I'd save that information until the last possible moment or sneak it into a response. If I'm revealed the cop or doctor I'd sit on it until after the nightkill, I'm okay with that information perishing with me.

 

[blybrook PE]

I think the current balance is good, especially with a non-PM round. It keeps everyone on their toes and makes you think more about the game.

 

[Tiger15]

IMO, the think the Cassandra should get a vision at night and be required to post before the day lynch. I don't think I like the 24 hour requirement.

Thoughts?

 

[DLD PE]

IMO, the think the Cassandra should get a vision at night and be required to post before the day lynch. I don't think I like the 24 hour requirement.

Thoughts?

That's how I directed the Cassandra role this round. It depends on the definition of "night". I gave @EyehatethePEexam PE their vision right after the lynch was announced (8PM). This was convenient for me as well, since I could get all my postings in around the same time. I gave @EyehatethePEexam PE up until the following lynch to post their vision, which is 24 hours.

@jean15paul_PE did you have something different in mind, such as wait longer to give the Cassandra their vision? Early in the morning perhaps?

 

[BlueBlueprintPE PMP]

Happy St. Patrick's Day!!!

 

[BlueBlueprintPE PMP]

And I'm in for next round whenever it may be! Can also mod a round (no frills/boring half-assed storyline) if needed.

 

[BlueBlueprintPE PMP]

and triple!

 

[Tiger15]

That's how I directed the Cassandra role this round. It depends on the definition of "night". I gave @EyehatethePEexam PE their vision right after the lynch was announced (8PM). This was convenient for me as well, since I could get all my postings in around the same time. I gave @EyehatethePEexam PE up until the following lynch to post their vision, which is 24 hours.

@jean15paul_PE did you have something different in mind, such as wait longer to give the Cassandra their vision? Early in the morning perhaps?

I guess "night" is a pretty vague term.

IMO, the Cassandra should receive the vision sometime after the day lynch and before (or at the same time as) the nightkill is announced. I.e. sometime during the night phase. And have to reveal before the next day lynch.

 

[Eng_Girl95]

I guess "night" is a pretty vague term.

IMO, the Cassandra should receive the vision sometime after the day lynch and before (or at the same time as) the nightkill is announced. I.e. sometime during the night phase. And have to reveal before the next day lynch.

But that’s exactly how it was played wasn’t it?

 

[Tiger15]

But that’s exactly how it was played wasn’t it?

Didn't the Cassandra receive a vision and wait until after the lynch to reveal?
... Or did I misunderstand?

 

[DLD PE]

Didn't the Cassandra receive a vision and wait until after the lynch to reveal?
... Or did I misunderstand?

My routine after work each day is:

Leave work around 5pm, drive 45 mins home, eat dinner with wife and Mini-Me, play with Mini-Me until time to read books (about 7:30). He only allows me to read one book, so wife reads the next two or three and puts him to bed, around 8pm. So I have a 10-15 min window to myself where I can catch up on votes, announce the lynch, etc. Then starting around 8:15-8:30 my wife and I are watching whatever show we're on (we just finished "Hannah" and now watching the Jack Ryan series). This is why I have a difficult time keeping up with the votes between 5-8pm.

Because of this, I told @EyehatethePEexam PE the same thing I told @jean15paul_PE ...that "night" is a vague term. Therefore, I told @EyehatethePEexam PE I would give them their vision right after the lynch. So 8pm comes, I announce the lynch, then right after that I send Eye their vision. I gave @EyehatethePEexam PE until the following 8pm lynch time to reveal their vision.

 

[Eye Hate Landscaping PE]

Didn't the Cassandra receive a vision and wait until after the lynch to reveal?
... Or did I misunderstand?

No, I received the vision after the lynch. I relayed that information before the nightkill, except for becca as cop- I waited until after the nightkill to reveal that one.

 

[steel]

No, I received the vision after the lynch. I relayed that information before the nightkill, except for becca as cop- I waited until after the nightkill to reveal that one.

I think that’s what jean doesn’t like. You waited more than 24 hours to reveal your intel. Which means you should have been lynched by default and not Becca.

 

[MeowMeow PE]

I think that’s what jean doesn’t like. You waited more than 24 hours to reveal your intel. Which means you should have been lynched by default and not Becca.

No he did not wait more than 24 hours. He revealed the vision to the group within a few hours of receiving it.

 

[Tiger15]

Gotcha. Sorry. I misunderstood the timing

 

[DLD PE]

No he did not wait more than 24 hours. He revealed the vision to the group within a few hours of receiving it.

Correct. Most of the time @EyehatethePEexam PE revealed the info soon after the reveal. He never exceeded the 24 hour limit.