EB Mafia

[RBHeadge PE]

But by all means, people shouldn't use this as an opportunity to dogpile. The other players should vote as they see fit. I/we need more diversity in the voting record to piece it all together. Especially votes from these players:
cheb, meow, eyehate, txj, spit, mp, vhab, eyehate

 

[RBHeadge PE]

 

[Eng_Girl95]

@BlueBlueprintPE I vote for @MadamPirate PE

She voted for me, and was one of only two players that voted for someone other than Eye, chart, or MP.

 

[txjennah PE]

@BlueBlueprintPE I vote for @MadamPirate PE

@RBHeadge PE I voted for Madam yesterday as well.

 

[steel]

For what it's worth from a , I think we had good voting diversity yesterday. Everyone had their reasons for voting for one of three players that all seemed equally suspicious.

Should help the town cause like @eng_girl95 mentioned, only two votes were not for one of those three. (I hope that doesn't count as contributing to game play since I was just repeating another player!)

 

[DLD PE]

My first instinct was to vote for @MeowMeow PE to get a discussion going.

Looking back, @steelnole15 was 100% the obvious doc save, which means the doc is new or inactive or was super busy. Likewise, it's possible the mafia were inactive or super busy, or just decided after two lynches to make a desperate move and take a chance. @steelnole15 would have been the last on my list to nightkill if I were mafia. We didn't have a nightkill on Day 1, which leans me thinking toward inactive players.

@BlueBlueprintPE I vote for @ChebyshevII PE for the time being.

 

[steel]

My first instinct was to vote for @MeowMeow PE to get a discussion going.

Looking back, @steelnole15 was 100% the obvious doc save, which means the doc is new or inactive or was super busy. Likewise, it's possible the mafia were inactive or super busy, or just decided after two lynches to make a desperate move and take a chance. @steelnole15 would have been the last on my list to nightkill if I were mafia. We didn't have a nightkill on Day 1, which leans me thinking toward inactive players.

@BlueBlueprintPE I vote for @ChebyshevII PE for the time being.

Things like this get sooooo good once the game ends and we find out who the special roles were and what all happened behind the scenes!

 

[Spitfire6532]

I am following the inactive night kill logic, it seems to have worked yesterday, and if even one of the two remaining inactive from the first night turns out to be mafia, that's looking huge for a town win. I am less certain about Eyehate, so...

@BlueBlueprintPE I vote for @MadamPirate PE

 

[txjennah PE]

My first instinct was to vote for @MeowMeow PE to get a discussion going.

Looking back, @steelnole15 was 100% the obvious doc save, which means the doc is new or inactive or was super busy. Likewise, it's possible the mafia were inactive or super busy, or just decided after two lynches to make a desperate move and take a chance. @steelnole15 would have been the last on my list to nightkill if I were mafia. We didn't have a nightkill on Day 1, which leans me thinking toward inactive players.

@BlueBlueprintPE I vote for @ChebyshevII PE for the time being.

Why was he the obvious choice? Didn't he just use a wheel to take out square?

 

[MadamPirate PE]

@BlueBlueprintPE I vote for @MadamPirate PE because that ***** deserves it.

Also because work sucks.

 

[beccabun PE]

@BlueBlueprintPE I vote for @MadamPirate PE because that ***** deserves it.

Also because work sucks.

I didn't realize who posted this at first and I was like "jeez this round is getting intense!"

 

[steel]

Why was he the obvious choice? Didn't he just use a wheel to take out square?

Because I'm ******* awesome? lol

 

[DLD PE]

Why was he the obvious choice? Didn't he just use a wheel to take out square?

Because of what he posted in bold yesterday. He was basically calling himself out as the Cassandra in hopes the doc would notice and put the save on him. That's how I read it anyway.

 

[blybrook PE]

What a way to start the day... Some good laughs here.

I agree that we might have an inactive mafia group, potentially a slightly inactive cop / doctor.

Looking at the activity levels, MadamPirate PE has stated she's recently swamped with work. Same with EyehatethePEexam PE (hence my vote for them yesterday). Very few posts from others. Hard to get reads right now.

At the moment, @BlueBlueprintPE current vote is for @ChebyshevII PE (the kids will enjoy playing with the dogs). Subject to change if additional information comes out through the day.

 

[ChebyshevII PE PMP]

@BlueBlueprintPE my vote goes to @DLD PE. Having played co-mafia with him before I suspect he's up to his old tricks.

 

[RBHeadge PE]

Why was he the obvious choice? Didn't he just use a wheel to take out square?

see below:

My way too early reads:


Tilt town: nole, jean, becca, rbh, bly
Tilt maf: eyehate
Idk: dld, vhab
Neutral: everyone else

Tilt=ever so slight leaning. Far from clear evidence.

Rationale:
nole: voted for square. It a first vote so less potential utility value
Becca, rbh: noticed and pointed out or echoed squares gif use and maf "tell"
Jean: general town leanings of posts, pointed out poor hypothetical game theory by eyehate
Bly: elected not to create a threeway tie. Which had effect of providing some town utility. Would have been a negative utility move for mafia, implies he is town
Eyehate: see above. Sus, but not really convincing of guilt. Wouldn't recommend voting to lynch them based on this alone.
Dld vhab: noted the square mafia rules meme and didn't vote for him. Probably not an indication of anything.

I agree. Bly is a regular townie.

emphasis his.

He pretty much said that he was either the cassandra or the cop. And fwiw, there weren't many other posts yesterday that could have come from the cassandra.

 

[ChebyshevII PE PMP]

But by all means, people shouldn't use this as an opportunity to dogpile. The other players should vote as they see fit. I/we need more diversity in the voting record to piece it all together. Especially votes from these players:
cheb, meow, eyehate, txj, spit, mp, vhab, eyehate

I think your player list needs more diversity. Listing eyehate twice...rookie mistake.

 

[steel]

 

[beccabun PE]

@BlueBlueprintPE i vote for @ChebyshevII PE

 

[ChebyshevII PE PMP]

Seriously, guys. Not mafia. I promise.