Jump to content
Engineer Boards

​ ​ ​
a4u2fear

For people who've taken PE exam multiple times

Recommended Posts

How similar have you found all of the exams you have taken?  Similar in difficulty and questions?

 

I just took it for my first time and failed.  I did not have a lot of time to prepare and I have kids which made it even more difficult.  However, after reviewing all of the material and practice exams from multiple sources, I was nearly 100% of at least a few different problems that would've been on there...that weren't.  It was surprising.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
23 hours ago, a4u2fear said:

How similar have you found all of the exams you have taken?  Similar in difficulty and questions?

 

I just took it for my first time and failed.  I did not have a lot of time to prepare and I have kids which made it even more difficult.  However, after reviewing all of the material and practice exams from multiple sources, I was nearly 100% of at least a few different problems that would've been on there...that weren't.  It was surprising.

They were different. The first time was more conceptual and very little mathematical. The second time was more mathematical. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There were a few similar type of questions but the majority were completely different. Unfortunately this test will most likely require you to expand your knowledge. Good luck and keep at it!

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 5/29/2018 at 9:31 AM, a4u2fear said:

How similar have you found all of the exams you have taken?  Similar in difficulty and questions?

 

I just took it for my first time and failed.  I did not have a lot of time to prepare and I have kids which made it even more difficult.  However, after reviewing all of the material and practice exams from multiple sources, I was nearly 100% of at least a few different problems that would've been on there...that weren't.  It was surprising.

I had to take the PE exam twice. Both pretty damn different from my memory and experience. Not only that, but as someone else mentioned, they also switched between conceptual and mathematical. Second time [felt] harder yet I passed. 

For the second time, I studied even harder and gathered up more practice exams (first time I had about 5, second I had about 9 or 10). It was tough but just keep trying no matter how many times it may take you. DONT.GIVE.UP. You WILL pass I promise. Truly try to understands the basics. Keep it simple. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 5/29/2018 at 12:31 PM, a4u2fear said:

How similar have you found all of the exams you have taken?  Similar in difficulty and questions?

 

I just took it for my first time and failed.  I did not have a lot of time to prepare and I have kids which made it even more difficult.  However, after reviewing all of the material and practice exams from multiple sources, I was nearly 100% of at least a few different problems that would've been on there...that weren't.  It was surprising.

you need to be 100% ready for conceptuals. if you still have questions on those, then you're going to be SOL every time

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On ‎6‎/‎14‎/‎2018 at 2:02 AM, Convolution said:

I had to take the PE exam twice. Both pretty damn different from my memory and experience. Not only that, but as someone else mentioned, they also switched between conceptual and mathematical. Second time [felt] harder yet I passed. 

For the second time, I studied even harder and gathered up more practice exams (first time I had about 5, second I had about 9 or 10). It was tough but just keep trying no matter how many times it may take you. DONT.GIVE.UP. You WILL pass I promise. Truly try to understands the basics. Keep it simple. 

Sounds like a recipe for success.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I passed on my third time so I know how frustrating it can be.  My first two times were in the late 90's.  I got gun shy and did not attempt again until 2014.  Obviously tests that were that far apart were totally different.  I will say if you have to take it multiple times focus more  on test taking strategy.  Spinup has a great strategy in that you use a multiple pass approach to answer questions.  it requires an initial evaluation of all the questions and assigning a point system 1-5

  • Answer easy questions that don't require looking at material
  • Answer NEC/NESC questions.  Using one pass to focus on Code means you don't go back and forth between Code books and the rest of your material.  (Complex Imaginary' s NEC prep book is EXTREMELY helpful)
  • Answer questions which only require a quick look at reference material
  • Answer questions which require a longer look at reference material
  • Guess on the rest.  Pick whatever letter/number that is trending on the other answers

Also, by the time I made my third attempt the internet was in full effect.  From a resource standpoint that made a world of difference.  As I was studying, if I did not know the answer to a study question I'd Google and was able to find what I needed a significant number of times.

Finally, if you haven't done so, take a review course. I have kids also and had a limited amount time to study.  A good course can flatten the learning curve while giving you good structure. I found the GA Tech course to be extremely helpful. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is a long overdue post. After I took my PE exam in April, I had thought to myself " If I pass, I definitely have to write a post about how it is not a difficult to task to pass the PE", but here I am, still not done that. So let me start.

I took my PE first time in October of 2017. I started studying in September, I wasn't sure where to begin from and I only had a month and a half, so I took the School of PE review course. The reason I took this course was, because they really helped me when I was studying for my FE and I had passed FE in my first attempt.  But for PE, I wasn't very happy with their classes. I remember the professor who took transmission  just read through the presentation. The practice problems were also not up to the mark.  I also used Graffeo, as that was the general recommendation and also heard that there were a lot of problems in the April 2017 exam similar to Graffeo.  Anyways, so I studied with the help of the SOPE materials and Graffeo, took two Complex Imaginary tests , the main NCEES test, Graffeo exam and the PPI exam. 

So when I took the CBTE FE exam, the mock test provided with it was extremely difficult, after taking it , I wasn't sure how I would pass the FE , though I had studied for  4 months, but it was different when I took the PE power mock exam and the other practice tests. All of them were of average difficulty. Some were really easy.  Even with only 1.5 months of studying, when I took the NCEES practice exam, I felt confident for the real test since I was expecting the questions  to be in par with the practice tests. 

Lo and behold, I was in for a BIG SURPRISE, the real exam is not even close to the practice tests. 😡 The real exam was difficult. All those practice exams I took , gave me  false hope, as those exams did not have the same standard as the real test. There were those logical questions which you can easily figure out and then there are those concepts which you know is hiding in one of the references, but if you aren't well versed with your references, there is no way you will be able to find all those answers. I had to go through all ( two references I had ) my materials to find the answer. 

Lessons Learnt: BEWARE, DO NOT FALL FOR THOSE PRACTICE TESTS THAT'S OUT THERE, THEY ARE NOT CLOSE TO THE REAL TEST. 

So two months later when the results came, I wasn't surprised. I enjoyed Christmas and started fresh again in January, joined Engineers Board , started following feeds and advises by previous test takers.  

How I did it:

My references: 

1. Graffeo ( this is a very good book to refresh your concepts), but my book had a lot of errors and I was getting mad because I couldn't understand how they were arriving at certain equations or answers. Then I read in this forum about how Graffeo replies to emails. So I emailed all my questions and I must say, I was very surprised by Graffeos prompt response. This is a very good starter book. 

2.  School of PE materials: I  went through it again. I think I forgot to mention before, the professor who took the Machines class was good. He had taken the effort to go through the basic concepts. I went through the materials and solved every problem. Though personally I dint think there was any questions from SOPE that was close to the real exam, though solving problems did help improve my concepts

3. Wildi: Again, I read about this book through this forum and I must say , this book is really good and came in VERY handy during the real exam. Remember how I mentioned about how I knew those concepts were hidden somewhere , basically it was hidden in Wildi. One of the members had posted about the chapters he read and found useful, I followed that and started placing tabs on pages I though was important. 

4. Power system analysis : This book was recommended by one member. It dint help me much during the exam, but apparently it helped some. 

5. Art of science of protective relaying: I think two weeks before the exam someone mentioned about this book and how with the change in pattern , the new exam could give importance to Protection. Yes, that member was totally right, as during the second part of the exam this portion was given a lot of importance and they were definitely not easy to solve. This may be one of the reasons why April 2018 exam was considered tougher compared to the other years. So do give importance to this portion. I personally wasn't able to find much help through this book, but if you have the time, do try to understand protective relaying and devices. There is also a free handout by GE which was considered good by some.

5. FE manual: I never used it, but later through the forums I understood a lot of members found this very handy during the first part of the exam. 

6. Personal Binder: Like most test takers have mentioned, have your own binder with your formulas, drawings, PDFs( of portions not covered in books). Also tab them, you dont want to spend time looking for them during the test. I also found formula sheet on Engineering Pro guide website, which was  helpful. 

Practice tests: 

I started taking practice tests by February mid and tried taking one test per week. 

PPI exam: One and Two- Difficulty level- 6

Graffeo : Behind the book exam - Difficulty level -5

Complex Imaginary (1-4): Difficulty level - 3

NCEES practice: This is good, but the difficulty level is  6

Engineering Pro Guide(Full exam) : Difficulty level - 8 This is the best of the lot. I am so glad that I found it. This exam covers a lot. Just doing this exam makes you understand a lot of topics. It covers almost all topics.

So even if the real exam is much more difficult compared to the practice tests,  I would say by doing these tests and understanding the solutions will improve your concepts and understanding of the subject. 

On the day of the exam:

I was lucky we were given a smaller room to sit in, which means less noise and luckily for me , the seat next to me was empty. Which means  more space to keep my books. 😂

Morning session: I went through the questions and I was like " what the hell'. I couldn't understand anything. Anyways the strategy was to do the easy ones first, once I started doing that, I started to gain confidence. Then I went to do the NEC questions, got stuck in some but got most. (TIP: carry the handbook , if you get stuck , the examples and pictures will help you solve some of the question). Next I did the difficult ones. I must say, at first the questions looked tricky, but when read two or three times , you may realize it is actually pretty straightforward. 

Lunch: I got my lunch, looked for an empty table and wrote down all the questions I couldn't solve. I think I had 8. This exercise really helped me. I knew where I went wrong and i would say everyone should do that. This will make you confident after the test is over or if not, this will at least help you the next time you write the exam, as you may never know , the same style question could be repeated.:) 

Afternoon Session: I don't know what happened here, but this session turned out to be wonderful for me. I started with the first question and I was like ' This is easy', then question 2, 3...it went on and from the 40 questions, I would say at least 30 of those could be answered easily, if your concepts are good. I was stumped by the protection questions, most of which I could only guess. So do spend time understanding protection. 

After the exam was over, I let my friend drive while I wrote down all the questions that I couldn't answer, thinking to myself, if I don't pass this time, I don't know what to do next. :P 

On May 24th we got our results and I saw the Green sign. 😄

Also in retrospect, if I were to write the PE again (Thank God I don't have to), for difficult questions , I would give it a try and if I don't get a solution, I will go back to the ones I was confident about , recheck the solution and only then come back  to the questions I am having trouble with, as I spent more time than necessary for some hard questions.

This is just my take. 

So test takers, do not worry, if you have studied hard, there is nothing to worry. 

PS: Make sure you get all those 12 NEC questions right, they will try to trick you by making you think the answer isn't there, but the solution is just hiding somewhere in the bottom :P

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

SSG thanks for posting.  I've been studying since March, and really putting a lot of hours in since July.  I've taken three practice exams but they've all been from the  NCEES.  I was planning to do Complex Imaginary or Graffeos this week but I've been hearing so much praise on the Eng Pro Guides practice exam (I have their free formula sheet) that I decided to spend the $40 and download it.  I think I'll take that one next.  

I'm also taking Zach Stone's online course which I highly recommend.  We just covered protection so I'm hoping in the next few weeks I can really get a handle on the protection material.  I have both the Blackburn and GE books on relaying.  I was told the GE was "light and simple" but I downloaded it and it's 357 pages long lol.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@MEtoEE I did take some of Zach Stone's free courses and they were good, especially the one he teaches about PU. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×