Short Circuit Calcs- which method?

Professional Engineer & PE Exam Forum

Help Support Professional Engineer & PE Exam Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
P

Platinum

Hey guys,

Was wondering which method you guys use when a fault current question pops up in the exam. I learned symmetrical components within the last year, but when i took the exam last october, the short ckt questions they asked did not have any neg or zero sequence impedances given. They didnt seem that complex and i remember they didnt specify what type of fault it was (L-L, L-G?). So if they don't say what type of fault it is, do i assume its a balanced 3-phase fault?

Thanks for your thoughts.

 
In the practice problems and elsewhere, I don't remember seeing a symmetrical components problem and the type of fault was usually implicit from the nature of the problem. I've heard rumors of symmetrical components questions before but didn't see any personally in my limited P.E. experience. Anybody else? In contrast, I also don't remember seeing any illumination problems in the NCEES practice problems but did see them elsewhere.

 
Stay tuned. I have some cheat sheets to deal with sckt calculations depending, of course, on the type of fault. Right now I don't remember where I have them but I am sure they are upstairs on one of my binders. Give me a few days and I will get it for you my friend. I remember solving one of the problems on the test using it. You have to have a calc that deals with magnitudes and angles properly. I am sure that once you see the methods it will be easy for you to select which one you will use.

I'll be back :popcorn:

 
Stay tuned. I have some cheat sheets to deal with sckt calculations depending, of course, on the type of fault. Right now I don't remember where I have them but I am sure they are upstairs on one of my binders. Give me a few days and I will get it for you my friend. I remember solving one of the problems on the test using it. You have to have a calc that deals with magnitudes and angles properly. I am sure that once you see the methods it will be easy for you to select which one you will use.
I'll be back :reading:
That would help out a lot Luis, thanks.

There was one symmetrical components question last exam, but it was easy, just solving for Ia,b,c given I0,1,2.

But I'm lost when it comes to fault problems, mostly because i dont know which method to use.

There's point-to-point, MVA, sym comps, Ohmic, etc..... arrgh

 
That would help out a lot Luis, thanks.There was one symmetrical components question last exam, but it was easy, just solving for Ia,b,c given I0,1,2.

But I'm lost when it comes to fault problems, mostly because i dont know which method to use.

There's point-to-point, MVA, sym comps, Ohmic, etc..... arrgh
Make sure you read the question and understand the result that is required. That sounds really obvious, but the mind is great at taking shortcuts and coming to conclusions before you've finished reading the problem!

Have a look at this article The Art of Protecting Electrical Systems, Part 8

I lucked out and didn't see symetrical components on the test I took, but you always need to allow for the fact that it could be there. There really is no way that the test can be comprehensive with just 40 depth questions. So, you need to prepare for anything even though you will only see a tenth of that on the exam.

Also, let me know if you need a good reference for the MVA stuff. I have it in hardcopy, but I could probably find a link to it somewhere on the web.

 
Make sure you read the question and understand the result that is required. That sounds really obvious, but the mind is great at taking shortcuts and coming to conclusions before you've finished reading the problem!
Have a look at this article The Art of Protecting Electrical Systems, Part 8

I lucked out and didn't see symetrical components on the test I took, but you always need to allow for the fact that it could be there. There really is no way that the test can be comprehensive with just 40 depth questions. So, you need to prepare for anything even though you will only see a tenth of that on the exam.

Also, let me know if you need a good reference for the MVA stuff. I have it in hardcopy, but I could probably find a link to it somewhere on the web.
Yes, any references you have on short ckt stuff would be much appreciated. Let me know if you have a pdf or the link.

Thanks singlespeed

 
Stay tuned. I have some cheat sheets to deal with sckt calculations depending, of course, on the type of fault. Right now I don't remember where I have them but I am sure they are upstairs on one of my binders. Give me a few days and I will get it for you my friend. I remember solving one of the problems on the test using it. You have to have a calc that deals with magnitudes and angles properly. I am sure that once you see the methods it will be easy for you to select which one you will use.
I'll be back :reading:
\

\HEY LUIS DO YOU SOME OF THOSE CHEAT SHEETS AVAILABLE. I WOULD LIKE TO VIEW THEM AND COMPARE THEM TO SOME FORMULAS I HAVE. ANY HELP IS GREATLY APPREICATED. THANKS TO ALL.

 
Make sure you read the question and understand the result that is required. That sounds really obvious, but the mind is great at taking shortcuts and coming to conclusions before you've finished reading the problem!
Have a look at this article The Art of Protecting Electrical Systems, Part 8

I lucked out and didn't see symetrical components on the test I took, but you always need to allow for the fact that it could be there. There really is no way that the test can be comprehensive with just 40 depth questions. So, you need to prepare for anything even though you will only see a tenth of that on the exam.

Also, let me know if you need a good reference for the MVA stuff. I have it in hardcopy, but I could probably find a link to it somewhere on the web.
Nice articles SSpeed

 
This was always one of my weak areas, but to be honest, I have no idea what any of the terminology is and simply attacked the PE problems with circuit theory and geometry and the ones on the practice exam and Oct exam were not all that bad.

Of course, I have no idea if I got them right or not ;)

 
Another good place to find short circuit info / cheat sheets is the fuse manufacturers. Bussman and Ferraz-Shawmut put out a lot of free info on both quick and detailed short circuit methods. I used a free book I got from shawmut on the exam, it helped a lot with the minor amount of short circuit stuff I saw. Check out their websites, I'm sure you can find some stuff to download.

Chaos

 
The MVA Method pdf file is too large to upload here. PM me with your email and I'll send it to you if you're interested.

 
Back
Top