What to do?

Professional Engineer & PE Exam Forum

Help Support Professional Engineer & PE Exam Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
wvgirl14

wvgirl14

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2008
Messages
219
Reaction score
1
Location
Pipestem, :::::::::::::::wv:::::::::::::::
I have a interesting quandary. I recently took the FE Exam, and am awaiting results. I have been mulling this decision over for awhile and thought I would get some feedback and advice. If and when I do pass the FE I would like to start trying to study and earn my PE. Here is where I have the issue. I have enough professional experience to sit, but what to PE exam to take is the question. My degree is in Architectural Engineering (and I have seen the post about this not being a engineering field so don't bother responding if you are going to go there) and I also have an Associates in Civil Engineering (I only lack 4 class from a Bachelors and should have taken them but that is another story). I worked 3 years in the A/E world as a Assistant Project Manager and Architectural Design Technician for a small Architectural firm. Basically I assisted the Structural Designer and work on some basic Electrical and Mechanical Design, but mostly took care of the Civil Design and working on designing the contract documents and working drawings. I left the A/E firm and have spent 3 years in a Engineering Consulting firm as a Permit Assistant and Staff Engineer. I work on Surface Mining Application (please don't give me feedback on your political view of this), NPDES Permit, and Perform the Calculations and Design Refuse Disposal Facilities. I do some drainage work and pipe design. So here in lies the question do I take the Architectural PE exam or do I take the Civil and if I do take the Civil which Civil? I have all of my A/E college books, but there are not many references for the A/E PE exam plus I know it is heavy mechanical, electrical, and structural and I didn't get into alot of that. So help me out guys what is your opinion?

 
elementary advice here i guess - look over the exam contents for the PE Architectural, PE Civil (water resources & environmental depth), and lastly the PE Environmental (ncees website) - that seems to be where your experience in civil lies is towards the enviro end of things, just based on what youve said above.

You should glean from the exam pdf's what subject matter seems closest to your area or youre most comfortable with

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Ditto what EM says. Based on your description, it sounds to me like you'll want to take a civil exam but still need to decide on the appropriate depth module. Also, remember that part of the PE application is to provide professional references and a description of your work expereince. The expereince part should be consistent with the dicipline that your taking the test in and not necessarily greared towards your college studies. My :2cents:

Good luck.

 
in most states when you submit your application they will tell you based on your experience which exam your sitting for

 
Road Guy said:
in most states when you submit your application they will tell you based on your experience which exam your sitting for
Click to expand...
Really? I only applied in WA and OR, but both times they had me specifically indicate what I was applying for. And more to the point, I have found the state boards don't necessarily know much about engineering.

I mean I am sure some of the employees do, but from the times we spoke on the phone, they understood how to fill out their forms, but not real engineering practice.

 
Look at the specific areas each exam covers and take the one you think you have the highest chances of passing. In my state you can take the PE in one area and it will follow you into other areas if your competence changes. Not sure if your state is the same or not though.

 
Road Guy said:
in most states when you submit your application they will tell you based on your experience which exam your sitting for
Click to expand...


D. Kephart said:
Really? I only applied in WA and OR, but both times they had me specifically indicate what I was applying for. And more to the point, I have found the state boards don't necessarily know much about engineering.
Click to expand...
Hmm, i've never heard of that either - seems like it would make studying pretty difficult if you're waiting for your state board to tell you which exam you will actually be taking, for Civil depths anyways.

 
well in georgia thats how it was, I filled out the forms and they sent me back a letter and said your taking this test..

they tell you if your taking civil, mechanical, structural, etc they dont specify what afternoon section your taking

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Road Guy said:
well in georgia thats how it was, I filled out the forms and they sent me back a letter and said your taking this test..
they tell you if your taking civil, mechanical, structural, etc they dont specify what afternoon section your taking
Click to expand...
Are you referring to the Country of Georgia?

 
error_matrix said:
elementary advice here i guess - look over the exam contents for the PE Architectural, PE Civil (water resources & environmental depth), and lastly the PE Environmental (ncees website) - that seems to be where your experience in civil lies is towards the enviro end of things, just based on what youve said above.
You should glean from the exam pdf's what subject matter seems closest to your area or youre most comfortable with
Click to expand...
i'll second this, and go further and say buy a few of the sample exams and see which you do best at.

 
Road Guy said:
well in georgia thats how it was, I filled out the forms and they sent me back a letter and said your taking this test..
they tell you if your taking civil, mechanical, structural, etc they dont specify what afternoon section your taking
Click to expand...
but you have to tell them which area you feel you are the most proficient

http://sos.georgia.gov/acrobat/PLB/09%20PE...Application.pdf

page 9, question 6.

edit:

actually I guess your endorser tells the board which area you are the most proficient in.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
wvgirl14 said:
I am planning to take it in VA, but I am working in :wv: , most of the guys I know have done this as well.
Click to expand...
curious - why? and how does that enable you to practice engineering in WV?

 
Last edited by a moderator:
error_matrix said:
curious - why? and how does that enable you to practice engineering in WV?
Click to expand...
He probably plans on getting a WV license through Comity.

I think it comes down to if you want to stamp drawings... Which drawings would you be expected to stamp... If it's piping/wastewater then I'd say go civil, if it's environmental drawings (which i'm not sure if there is such a thing), then go PE Env... And if I can't really help with the PE Arch since i don't really know what it's for either (vs an architecture license)...

If it's for a pay bonus then i'd recommend PE Civil with an emphasis in water or maybe construction (which supposedly is the easiest) since I think that would give you the most versatility for future advancement.

Congrats on the FE, and ARCH engineering is totally a sham ;)

 
Last edited by a moderator:
wvgirl14: Have you verified the education requirements? Some states require applicants to have a Bachelor's in either engineering, engineering technology or a combination from the areas of mathematical, physical or engineering sciences. Is an associates an option with additional experiences where you are going to be applying?

 
I do have a Bachelors in Architectural Engineering Technology also I am a girl, lol. Why VA a few reason actually. One I live very close to the line and do work in both state, the test site is closer, also not as many hoops in VA. I do plan to go through Comity. I have no promise of a promotion I am do this more for myself. I do appreciate the feedback.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
“Ditto (to all earlier replies),” based on the work experience you’ve described you’d do fine with the PE Civil Water Resources exam but don’t rule out PE Civil Construction, PE Civil Structural or PE Architectural either if that’s what you’re comfortable with.

In general (keeping it short), Architectural Engineers are hard to find and their education and experience can “initially” be overlooked. Yet many have become registered Structural (as in SE’s), Civil, Mechanical, Electrical and Architectural Engineers and have had, registered or not, well respected careers in many fields of the building and construction industry. In addition, for added insight on how your educational background is being viewed today by industry see page 32 of the Nov. 2nd 09 issue of ENR (No, I did not graduate from Penn State, but was born and raised in PA).

My engineering degree is also in Architectural Engineering as a 5 yr ABET accredited BSAE. However my work experience has been mostly Civil/Structural/Architectural, so my selection was somewhat easier on the application. Today I work as a Structural Engineer and I recently sat for the PE Civil Structural exam in October. Good Luck in your choice and keep as many of your college text books that you can find because you never know where you will be in 10 plus years. (Smile)

 
wvgirl14 said:
I have a interesting quandary. I recently took the FE Exam, and am awaiting results. I have been mulling this decision over for awhile and thought I would get some feedback and advice. If and when I do pass the FE I would like to start trying to study and earn my PE. Here is where I have the issue. I have enough professional experience to sit, but what to PE exam to take is the question. My degree is in Architectural Engineering (and I have seen the post about this not being a engineering field so don't bother responding if you are going to go there) and I also have an Associates in Civil Engineering (I only lack 4 class from a Bachelors and should have taken them but that is another story). I worked 3 years in the A/E world as a Assistant Project Manager and Architectural Design Technician for a small Architectural firm. Basically I assisted the Structural Designer and work on some basic Electrical and Mechanical Design, but mostly took care of the Civil Design and working on designing the contract documents and working drawings. I left the A/E firm and have spent 3 years in a Engineering Consulting firm as a Permit Assistant and Staff Engineer. I work on Surface Mining Application (please don't give me feedback on your political view of this), NPDES Permit, and Perform the Calculations and Design Refuse Disposal Facilities. I do some drainage work and pipe design. So here in lies the question do I take the Architectural PE exam or do I take the Civil and if I do take the Civil which Civil? I have all of my A/E college books, but there are not many references for the A/E PE exam plus I know it is heavy mechanical, electrical, and structural and I didn't get into alot of that. So help me out guys what is your opinion?
Click to expand...
I also hold a BS in AE. Who the hell says that is not an engineer field? Oy vey...the ignorance displayed on here is frightening. Any how...no matter what PE you take (and my suggestion is the AE PE) you're going to have to study material that you learned in the last two years of college, and some codes. If you decide to take the Civil exam, take the Construction PM. That is my 0.02!

 
So I finally passed the FE and am filling out my application for the PE. I am still a little unsure of the afternoon module to take. I decided I would take the Civil PE. For the past couple of years I have been designing coal refuse embankment and impoundments, so I am leaning toward taking the Geotechnical afternoon. I perform all the calculations and designs on these facilities, slope stabilities, dam breaks, pipe size, cut/fill areas, etc. I also have a ton of Geotechnical references (Das books included). I did purchase the six minute solutions and 201 problem book along with the CERM and companion book. I had it narrowed down to Water resources and Construction, but I have been away from the construction and frankly the code stuff scares me and with Water resources aside from doing sewage modification to permit bath house facilities on mine site I have no knowledge in waster water or any chemistry that may deal with. So am I destined for failure here or what. I am already into the CERM so i hope to have plenty of time to study before next April.

 

Similar threads

screeli
Architectural Engineering Ref Handbook limitations
Replies
4
Views
1K
youngmotivatedengineer
youngmotivatedengineer
M
New Member Doing Fiber OSP Design
Replies
3
Views
262
MasonFiber
M
B
Questions on Requirements For PE and SE Exams
Replies
4
Views
753
pgheng
P
K
Journey to acquire a PE License
Replies
1
Views
195
pgheng
P
I
Architectural, Civil, Structural Engineer - San Antonio, TX
Replies
0
Views
150
Ignatius82
I

Latest posts

Back
Top