If minimalistic shoes don't suit you, by all means switch! Or, I cycle through three shoes at any given time:
Big: Saucony Ride - this was the shoe I took out of Jackrabbit Running when I started paying attention to my shoes
Medium: New Balance Fresh Foam Zante - Saucony Kinvara has the reputation as the "perfect middle" shoe but I never liked them. This shoe delivered what I was looking for.
Lightweight: I used to wear Saucony Fastwitch for this purpose but I haven't liked successive updates. Now I have a pair of adidas Boost adios. I've heard the Boost Boston is a "slightly more cushioned" version of this shoe and I'll try it when my Zantes wear out.
I probably wear the Sauconys 50% of the time, the NBs 30% and the adidas 20%.